Volume > Issue > The Value of Our Enemies’ Lives

The Value of Our Enemies’ Lives

VITAL WORKS RECONSIDERED, #60

By Richard Upsher Smith Jr. |
Richard Upsher Smith Jr., a Contributing Editor of the NOR, is retired from teaching classics and honors at Franciscan University of Steubenville. After serving for 19 years in the Anglican ministry, he converted to Catholicism in 2001. He is the author, most recently, of A Quaker Colonel, His Fiancée, and Their Connections: Selected Civil War Correspondence (Lehigh University Press, 2023) and The Catholic Holy Sites of the Mohawk Valley: The True Locations of the Deaths of the Jesuit Martyrs of New York and of the Birth of St. Catherine Tekakwitha (Franciscan University Press, 2025).

Hombre. By Elmore Leonard.

Elmore Leonard’s western novel Hombre, published in 1961, is said to have led to a turn in cowboy stories toward grit and realism, and to have alerted readers to academia’s growing skepticism about American exceptionalism. It is said also to have shown the Apache as oppressed, and Anglos as oppressors, and so to have addressed racism in the civil rights era. It is even presented as depicting young people over against their elders, thus portraying the burgeoning youth rebellion of the time.

Though there might be some truth in each of these assertions, such issues merely provide the contours for Leonard’s deeper concerns. Hombre paints a grim picture of America — of mankind, really — and shows that the only salvation for our country, and for man, is the transformation of individuals in Christ.

On the face of it, this is not an absurd claim. Leonard (1925-2013) was a Jesuit-educated Catholic and went to daily Mass into early adulthood, though he drifted away from the Church later in life. Even so, he retained a Catholic way of looking at the world, and the clues are scattered throughout this book. But first, a brief account of the tale is in order.

Hombre describes a stagecoach robbery. An Indian agent, the Rev. Dr. Alexander Favor, has embezzled $12,000 (this is in 1884) by cheating the San Carlos Apache out of some of their government beef rations, leaving them to starve. Some of his beef suppliers have discovered his peculation and hold up the stagecoach he hired for his escape. Henry Mendez, the driver of the stage and the stage company’s agent, has taken the opportunity to make extra money by carrying more passengers. In addition to Dr. Favor and his wife, Audra, they are Frank Braden, one of the highwaymen, unknown to the other passengers for what he is; Carl Allen, a young, untried employee of the stage line; Kathleen McLaren, a teenage girl recently rescued from Apache captivity; and the protagonist, John Russell, a blue-eyed, Anglo-Mexican half-breed, captured as a child by the Apache and raised among them. As a teen, he spent a few years with an Anglo sponsor on a ranch, where he learned English and some Anglo ways. He later returned to the Apache and worked as a tribal policeman on the reservation. Now 21, he is on the stagecoach because he has inherited his sponsor’s ranch and is traveling to take possession of it and sell it.

The highwaymen steal Dr. Favor’s stolen funds and take Mrs. Favor hostage. They leave the other passengers in the middle of the desert mountains without horses or water, meaning for them to die. Russell kills a straggling highwayman and his horse and rescues a skin of water and the peculated funds. He takes a canteen for himself, leaves the skin with the other passengers, and, thinking like an Apache, hastens away higher into the mountains. The others hesitate to follow but realize they must.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

The Other War We Lost in Vietnam

President Johnson was seduced by his macho superpatriotism into the morass of Vietnam, and so the war against poverty was lost too.

A Davidic Similitude in Pre-Revolutionary China

All of us, regardless of our wealth or circumstances, are presented with choices that lead either to our happiness or to our ruin.

Manipulation, Murder & Madness

Macbeth. By William Shakespeare.

Due to publisher restrictions this article is not available on the…