Volume > Issue > Catholicism Confronts New Age Syncretism

Catholicism Confronts New Age Syncretism


By Bernard D. Green | April 1994
The Rev. Bernard D. Green, who was born and raised in England, is Associate Pastor of St. Odilia's Catholic Church in Tucson, Arizona. He also teaches New Testament at Pima Community College.

The National Catholic Reporter recently ran a story about the possibility that the Catholic feminist movement known as Women-Church was losing all connection with Catholic tra­dition. The underlying concern was that Women-Church, in its attempts to be inclusive of all women, was becoming syncretistic. That is, it was willing to accommodate many different spiritual traditions on an equal level with Catholic faith and practice. The report said that an upcoming Women-Church con­ference would have, in addition to rituals by witches, rituals led by “Buddhists, American Indians, Quakers and Jewish leaders — as well as by Catholic nuns.”

This syncretistic mentality is widespread in the Church today. Witness the following description of the program of a respected Midwestern Catholic cen­ter for spirituality:

Readings are selected every day from the sa­cred texts of Buddhism, Taoism, Hinduism, and Islam, as well as Christianity. On occasion, ancient festivals of the Celts or Saxons are re­membered, and members dance around a maypole or fire-pit in the fields or forest…. The Chapel is visually stimulating and instruc­tive…. Icons of Our Lady of Guadalupe and the Risen Christ are placed side by side with stat­ues of Buddha, Lord Vishnu and Moses.

The pervasiveness of this spiritual attitude, much influenced by New Age trendiness, challenges the foundations of our Church. At the same time, however, it offers us an opportunity to re-examine those foundations and ask ourselves just what it is that anchors our identity as Catholics.

Enjoyed reading this?



You May Also Enjoy

New Oxford Notes: October 2016

Centurions of the New Age... Islam Is Like Fruit Salad?

On Lutefisk, Latin & Liturgy

There is something undeniably bittersweet about the sublimation of a distinct culture into the flat, American consumerist anti-culture touted as an improvement.

The Fallacy of Faulty Analogy

Activists and journalists have been working overtime to make stick the comparison between racial segregation and so-called anti-LGBT attitudes.