Topics

From the NOR Dossiers

Just War Theory & the Iraq War

Neocon Hubris & the Battle for Ukraine

EVER THE WARMONGERS

Pieter Vree

September 2022

Pat Buchanan warned in 1999 about expanding NATO to include Ukraine: “By moving NATO onto Russia’s front porch, we have scheduled a 21st-century confrontation.”

VIEW ARTICLE
Unmasking Putin’s Rasputin

ON RESISTING EVIL BY FORCE

Jason M. Morgan

May 2022

If, God forbid, the need should arise, is it licit for a Christian to resist evil by force, to take up a weapon and kill an aggressor?

VIEW ARTICLE
Moving Beyond Nuclear Pro-Choice

DETERRENCE IS MORALLY UNACCEPTABLE IN ITS VERY FOUNDATION

Julianne Wiley

September 2021

The fact that some arguments against strategic nuclear deterrence are faulty does not permit the conclusion that there are no compelling moral arguments against it.

VIEW ARTICLE
Re-evaluating the Church’s Approach to Nuclear Weapons

TWO CHEERS FOR DETERRENCE

Andrew Latham

September 2021

Deterrence advocates acknowledge the intrinsic balefulness of war but argue nonetheless that the possibility of war is ever-present.

VIEW ARTICLE
The Blood Crying Out from the Ground
October 2014

We Westerners bear responsibility for the current sufferings in Iraq. We created a power vacuum there that has been filled by bloodthirsty maniacs hellbent on religious cleansing.

VIEW ARTICLE
The Woeful Plight of Iraqi Christians
November 2007

Christians in Iraq are perceived as being allied with the foreign occupiers, but the Americans provide no special protection for them.

VIEW ARTICLE
War & the Requirement of Moral Certainty

LAXISM

Emmanuel Charles McCarthy

March 2007

According to Catholic Just War norms, if there is not strict moral certitude that a war is just and is being conducted justly, then the war is unjust.

VIEW ARTICLE
Pro-Life & Pro-War?
January 2007

Fr. Pavone is a great prolife leader, but why can't he think with the mind of the Church instead of the mind of the Republican party?

VIEW ARTICLE
Should Catholics Defend America?

NEW OXFORD REVIEW LOCUTA EST, CAUSA FINITA EST

Paul R. Muessig

July/August 2006

The incongruity between her words and her actions substantially undercuts the Church's moral position on war, and has implications that go far beyond that.

VIEW ARTICLE
Do Our Troops "Support Our Troops"?
March 2006

U.S. troops should be President Bush's bedrock of support for his war in Iraq, but an astounding 46% of American soldiers do not approve.

VIEW ARTICLE
Kill 'Em!
January 2006

The National Catholic Register wants to soothe the consciences of Catholic soldiers who feels they violated the Fifth Commandment in Iraq.

VIEW ARTICLE
Terrorizing the Innocent

MURDER IN THE CATHEDRAL

Joe Wall

November 2005

Once the principle is adopted that you can ignore the Universal Moral Law for pragmatic reasons, the door is wide open for all types of evils to enter.

VIEW ARTICLE
Why the United Methodist Bishops' Stance Against the War on Terrorism Is Incoherent

PEACE BEGINS IN THE WOMB

Peter R. McGuire

March 2002

The same church Fathers who condemned war also condemned abortion. Here the moral credibility of the Methodist bishops collapses.

VIEW ARTICLE
Can Catholic Orthodoxy Transcend Political Ideology?

THE CASE OF IRAQ

Nicholas C. Lund-Molfese

April 1999

Rather than mustering the courage to stand alone, Catholics find it easier to follow popular American political opinion.

VIEW ARTICLE
War's Challenge to the Christian Conscience

William D. Miller

November 1989

To what extent can a political or value system “have its way” when confronted by an informed and resolute Catholic conscience?

VIEW ARTICLE
Thou Shalt Not Do Nuclear Murder, Nor Intend To

James G. Hanink

October 1988

Review of Nuclear Deterrence, Morality and Realism by John Finnis, Joseph M. Boyle Jr., and Germain Grisez

VIEW ARTICLE
Nuclear Deterrence, Christian Conscience, and the End of Christendom

NEEDED: THE COURAGE OF NON-CONFORMISM

John Finnis

July-August 1988

VIEW ARTICLE
Ethics and Military Operations

IS 'REALISM' THE ONLY WAY?

James A. Stegenga

May 1988

VIEW ARTICLE
The Spiritual Thrust of Just War Doctrine

DEALING WITH THE 'ENEMY WITHOUT' AND THE 'ENEMY WITHIN'

Richard J. Moux

March 1988

VIEW ARTICLE
Kurt Waldheim & Franz Jägerstätter: Contrasting Austrian Responses to the Unjust War

ON SPIRITUAL HEROISM

Gordon C. Zahn

November 1986

If we need heroes to honor, let them earn that designation by virtue of true sacrifice based on personal moral commitment.

VIEW ARTICLE
Seams in the Seamless Garment?

DISTINGUISHING BETWEEN INNOCENT & GUILTY HUMAN LIFE

Sheldon Vanauken

January-February 1986

If the Seamless Garment links the sparing of innocent human life with the sparing of guilty human life (the murderer or invader of the household or the invader of the country) then the Garment is full of seams.

VIEW ARTICLE
Saying a Humble, Compassionate & Joyful “Yes” to Life

A SPIRITUALITY OF PEACEMAKING — PART III

Henri J.M. Nouwen

November 1985

Resisting the forces of death is only meaningful when we are fully in touch with the forces of life we want to uphold.

VIEW ARTICLE
Saying “No” to Death in All Its Manifestations

A SPIRITUALITY OF PEACEMAKING — PART II

Henri J.M. Nouwen

October 1985

Real resistance requires the humble confes­sion that we are partners in the evil that we seek to resist. This is a very hard and seemingly endless dis­cipline.

VIEW ARTICLE
Peace, a Gift We Receive in Prayer

A SPIRITUALITY OF PEACEMAKING — PART I

Henri J.M. Nouwen

September 1985

Just as Jesus’ command to love one another cannot be seen as a part-time obligation, so too His call to peacemaking is unconditional, unlimited, and uncompromising.

VIEW ARTICLE
Principle vs. Prudence

LETTER FROM ENGLAND

Christopher Derrick

May 1985

“Priests and bishops and popes are usually good men, often very good men. But they’re still only men, not always capable of really heroic courage," said the theologian.

VIEW ARTICLE
Beyond “Left” & “Right”

ABORTION & NUCLEAR WAR

Peter Kreeft

April 1985

How can we honestly ask God to re­move the scourge of abortion from our land when we are prepared to abort entire other countries with nuclear fire and brimstone?

VIEW ARTICLE
“Americanist” Permissivism

Juli Loesch

September 1984

In principle, swatting down missiles before they explode and hurt somebody is morally permissible, even obligatory, if it can be done without violating moral norms.

VIEW ARTICLE
What Will World War III Be About?

LETTER FROM ENGLAND

Christopher Derrick

July-August 1984

There are many ways to cut this world’s cake in half and take sides. A Christian should presumably think in terms of the Church vs. the world.

VIEW ARTICLE
Roman Catholics & Central America

SEARCHING FOR PEACE

John R. Quinn

December 1983

The Church in North America is enriched by the example of the Church in Central America as it struggles for justice and human digni­ty.

VIEW ARTICLE