A Flight from Hunger, a Fight for Life
REFUGE ACROSS THE RIVER
In our political discourse, we use the terms Left and Right. Depending on your point of view, one or the other is evil. If someone on the Left is running for office, you will vote for the person on the Right, just out of spite, or vice-versa. But the Left and the Right are fundamentally the same. That’s because each, finally, isolates and separates the person. Members of the Left, while expressing humanitarian concern through support of various forms of government aid and socialized medicine, tend to live in demarcated, trendy areas. Visit the Boston Edison area of Detroit, for example, and you will find a clear line between a preserved, stylish area and another that is neglected, with many homes boarded up or abandoned. Meanwhile, members of the Right typically emphasize individual rights over social responsibility. Consequently, they are associated with laissez-faire economics, a suburban lifestyle, and gun ownership — in other words, the good of the individual prospering by his own merits. The most direct threat to individuality, however, is the inner-city abortion mill, where mothers are bullied by family members, boyfriends, or societal expectations to deny the good of their own individuality and that of their unborn child. Usually, members of the Right (no, not always), despite right-to-life talk, ignore or neglect such places.
Personalist philosophy — at the core of the thought of Emmanuel Mounier, Jacques Maritain, Peter Maurin, and Pope St. John Paul II, among others — is neither Right nor Left, because it refuses to place social good against individual, or individual good against social. Mr. Spock, of Star Trek fame, exposes himself to intense radiation to save the starship Enterprise. The good of the many, he explains to Captain Kirk, outweighs the good of the one. Very dramatic, Mr. Spock — but wrong. The personalist philosopher would explain to Mr. Spock that the person is both individual and communal, that he is of time and eternity. As a reality of time, he has the needs and goods of the individual; yet, as a reality of eternity, he embodies Godliness, within which he enjoys a community with all that is person as God is Person.
To bring all this home, I am going to tell a story with elements of both Right and Left. The story is about immigration and borders, yet it is also about a particular family and their unborn child.
On July 7, 2023, a Venezuelan family, the Bolano-Pimentels, consisting of a firmly bonded husband and wife and their five children, left the area of Maracay in the north-central part of the country to travel, mostly by bus, to Cúcuta, Colombia, just across the border. Their destination was the United States. A long, dangerous path lay ahead, and some might condemn Carlos and Yennifer’s decision to expose their children to the dangers. Carlos, though, explains their decision very simply: In Venezuela they were starving. The middle son, Nehemías, was suffering from malnutrition. The whole family had experienced a diet that, for two weeks, consisted only of pumpkin and, as Carlos could catch them, an occasional possum or snake. The parents were not after the American Dream. They were after food and shelter.
The Bolano-Pimentels had barely begun their trip when their money ran out. They remained in Cúcuta for a month, living in a migrant shelter. The two older girls, Génesis and Betzaida, sang in the streets, and when that brought in a little money, Yennifer bought candy and sold that, too. When they had enough money, they bused to Medellín, and from there to Turbo, a port city in the far north of Colombia. A narrow gulf of the Caribbean, the Gulf of Arabá, forms a bay there between two parts of the country. On the other side of the bay, the family would begin at the bottom of Panamá with a journey through an area of the Panamanian jungle called El Darién.
You May Also Enjoy
My mother's frailty and slowness as she maneuvered her walker showed me how to dwell in the present, not giving in to stress and the pressure of the clock.
In modern-day America, human life is destroyed on a massive scale with the cruel, evil, and machine-like efficiency characteristic of the Nazis.
When our daughter was born, though she was not quite through the second trimester, she already had her own distinct personality and could smile.