Volume > Issue > Is Human Life “Sacred”? A Taidan with Kevin Doak

Is Human Life “Sacred”? A Taidan with Kevin Doak


By Jason M. Morgan | October 2021
Jason M. Morgan, a Contributing Editor of the NOR, teaches history, language, and philosophy at Reitaku University in Kashiwa, Japan. He is the author, most recently, of Law and Society in Imperial Japan: Suehiro Izutarō and the Search for Equity (Cambria Press, 2020).

When the U.S. Supreme Court decided Roe v. Wade and Doe v. Bolton as victories for the sexual revolution in 1973, abortion was still treated — even by the most vocal advocates of women’s liberation — as a regrettable but at times necessary procedure. Until just a few years ago, the rhetoric around abortion from its mainstream apologists was that it should be “safe, legal, and rare.”

In recent years, however, assaults on the human person have become increasingly brazen, and abortion rhetoric has followed suit. “Abortion on demand and without apology” has replaced “safe, legal, and rare.” Some women — for example, HBO star Lena Dunham — have even apologized for not having had an abortion yet. David Daleiden’s undercover videos of “medical researchers” haggling over the prices of fetal body parts and driving hard bargains — one former Planned Parenthood medical director wanted to “bump up” prices because, she said, “I want a Lamborghini” — provided a glimpse into the business of abortion, revealing how contemptuous many in our culture are toward human life.

In the gathering darkness, many pro-lifers have attempted to push back. Some have reached out to death-penalty opponents, anti-animal-cruelty organizations, or immigrant-protection organizations to try to strengthen their position. A common phrasing has emerged from these ecumenical encounters: that human life is sacred, or even that all life is sacred, period.

But what does the Catholic Church teach about life? Is all life, or all human life, really sacred? Georgetown University professor Kevin Doak, an expert on Japanese history and culture and, in particular, Catholic history and thought in Japan, and I recently engaged in a taidan (conversation) about this topic.

Enjoyed reading this?



You May Also Enjoy

These Are Family-Life Experts?

Trustworthy advice for parents who happen upon the "Your Family" page in Time magazine

The Christian View of Sex

Men and women today are tired of unfaithfulness, tired of shallow and brief relationships. They crave something more meaningful and reliable.

An Interview With a Carmelite

A Carmelite monastery in Wyoming is an exciting new element in the Church in America, and has proven to be fecund ground for vocations to the consecrated life.