Volume > Issue > Note List > Prolifers: Thanks for the Votes; We'll See You Again in Four Years

Prolifers: Thanks for the Votes; We’ll See You Again in Four Years

When Roe v. Wade (legalizing abortion nationwide) was upheld by the Supreme Court in Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992), three justices wrote the joint opinion saying that legal abortion is a matter of stare decisis — that is, upholding precedent, upholding settled law. The three who wrote that opinion were Justices Sandra Day O’Connor (appointed by Reagan), Anthony Kennedy (appointed by Reagan), and David Souter (appointed by Bush Sr.).

George W. Bush (Bush Jr.) said in several interviews before his inauguration in 2000 that Roe is “settled law.” Bush said he would not have a “litmus test” on abortion for his judicial nominees (just as Reagan and Bush Sr. said they would not). Nonetheless, prolifers voted in droves for Bush in 2004.

In a New Oxford Note (Jan. 2005, p. 19), we said: “We’d like to be proved wrong, but we believe that the Republicans will never outlaw abortion or insure that Roe v. Wade is reversed.”

However, neoconservative Fr. Frank Pavone, the National Director of Priests for Life, was campaigning for Bush in 2004, and he said at the 32nd-annual March for Life in 2005 that “I am very confident the President is going to nominate very prolife justices.”

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

Here Come the Catholic Cheerleaders

The Thomas More Law Center, founded by Tom Monaghan, has decided to support the nomination of Judge John Roberts, even though he called Roe v. Wade "the settled law of the land."

An Amazing Turn

She wanted to fly in and meet. At the airport, he was disappointed by how she looked in person. But by that stage in his life, he didn’t think he could do better.

The Treatment of Handicapped Infants

Wide-scale prenatal screening procedures brought about a “free-fire zone” on the defective child throughout all three stages of gestation.