Volume > Issue > Note List > Pie-Crust Pietism?

Pie-Crust Pietism?

There’s a monthly periodical by the name of New Covenant, which calls itself “A Magazine of Catholic Spirituality.” Its September issue has an editorial by Mike Aquilina, its Editor, entitled “On Shutting Up.” Aquilina tells us, “I cringe today when I recall long-ago conversations I had with grieving, anxious or depressed friends.” He says that, as a student of theology back then, he was “free in offering learned solutions to the problems of pain, evil and suffering.” But he’s since learned that “the best response to another’s pain is to keep two ears open….”

Aquilina tells us he has several friends who’ve “suddenly found themselves facing terrible adversities: family upheavals, personal rejection, job loss and lawsuits.” How to respond? He recalls the answers he used to give (as he imagines his friends heard them): “Blah blah God’s will blah blah we grow through our pain blah blah adversity blah blah offer it up.” Such answers, he says, “ring hollow.” Oh.

So now he favors “silent care.” His friends must be profoundly grateful. After all, why would they want answers or an opportunity to hear about offering it up — or even just plain good advice — when they can get silence and maybe a hug?

Aquilina says that to give silent care is to “imitate God” (who presumably never spoke a word or gave us The Word or blessed us with a Church to interpret His Word), and so he informs us that “My prayer this week is that I can shut up long enough to imitate my Lord….”

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

My Antonia, by Willa Cather

Willa Cather understands there’s a bleak side to the Romantic ideal of the American dream, a critical misinterpretation that the dream focuses on you rather than on others.

Letter to the Editor: October 2017

Just Another Form of Masculinity-Worship... Abjure All Factions... A Pseudo-Religion's Unknown Origins... A Blight & a Scourge... Return of the Mighty Hordes... It Ends with a Thud... One of Many Objections... A Check on the Temptation to Seek Structural Solutions... more

Combating Cultural Vandalism: The Scottish Example

It's hard not to be impressed by the Scottish bishops' consistent, powerful salvos fired at the Scottish government over same-sex marriage legislation.