Volume > Issue > Knowing About God, Knowing God

Knowing About God, Knowing God


By Glenn B. Siniscalchi | July-August 2011
Glenn B. Siniscalchi is a Ph.D. candidate in systematic theology at Duquesne University in Pittsburgh.

One of the traditional hallmarks of Catholic theology is that God’s existence can be known with certainty apart from the influence of authoritative, divine revelation. This longstanding belief of the Church can be said to have reached a climax at the First Vatican Council in 1870. In response to the prevailing trends of rationalism and fideism, the Council Fathers steered a middle course, declaring that God’s existence can be known through the natural light of human reason. This teaching was expressed in the Council’s “Dogmatic Constitution on the Catholic Faith,” Dei Filius.

Most Catholic theologians and philosophers vigorously defended this teaching well into the middle of the twentieth century. But almost immediately after the Second Vatican Council it fell out of favor; some scholars went so far as to argue that it was irrelevant to or even problematic for the flourishing of faith. Although the subject of natural theology is rarely applied to the practice of interreligious dialogue, the implication of the Council’s teaching is that theologians can indirectly demonstrate the fallacies inherent in non-theistic religions. Thus, the proofs for God’s existence are not just relevant to the Christian’s response to atheists, agnostics, and skeptics; they are applicable to the Catholic’s dialogue with followers of Buddhism, Confucianism, Jainism, and other non-theistic religions.

Enjoyed reading this?



You May Also Enjoy

On Science sans Context

Scientism is an attitude that fosters and promotes a seriously exaggerated — and hence distorted — estimation of the nature and the scope of science.

The Thomistic Critique of Theistic Evolution

Thomism is an integral part of the millennial flow of Western thought and cannot simply be consigned to the dustbin of misguided and superseded systems of philosophy.

Vatican II & Scholasticism

Until Vatican Council II, scholasticism, or, to speak more precisely, neo-scholasticism or neo-Thomism, had been…