Putting a “Positive Light” on Murder?
The Liguorian is one of those feel-good Catholic periodicals. It even has a subtitle: A Catholic Compass in a Changing World. Does that clarify anything? Whose Catholic Compass? There are so many these days. On the masthead it says: “Liguorian is an award-winning member of the Catholic Press Association.” Puh-leez! Every member of the Catholic Press Association wins an award for something eventually. Winning an award means nothing – and that’s just one reason we don’t belong to it.
The Liguorian Editor, Fr. William J. Parker, C.Ss.R., weighs in with an editorial called “To Dialogue or Demonize” (Feb.). Fr. Parker tells us that his Mom said, “If you can’t say something nice about someone, then don’t say anything at all.” Parker thinks this is great wisdom. In other words, if you can’t say something nice, refrain from speaking the truth. (And, indeed, the Liguorian is full of niceness.)
Apparently, the Blessed Virgin Mary did not give Jesus such advice. Jesus said some pretty nasty things to the Pharisees – and they were all true.
Parker says, “We need to find a way to dialogue with our opponents instead of demonizing them.” But Jesus didn’t dialogue with His opponents. Moreover, Jesus called the Pharisees “sons of Hell” (Mt. 23:15). That is demonizing to the max.
You May Also Enjoy
Our best hope with gang members and school dropouts is to walk the streets and work with those engaging in informal neighborhood conversation and encounters.
Dialogue as a pastoral effort to assist in a fuller appropriation of the truth is laudable, but dialogue as a way to mediate between truth and dissent is deception.
Springsteen describes a difficult, often lonely America, yet he is an idealist speaking of plain virtues — strength of will, hard work, generosity.