Volume > Issue > Whose Money Is It, Anyway?

Whose Money Is It, Anyway?

DON'T RUSH IN WHERE RUSH DOESN'T FEAR TO TREAD

By James K. Fitzpatrick | December 1995
James K. Fitzpatrick teaches high school in the suburbs of New York City.

Some of my best friends are free-market capitalists — well, okay, I guess I should say some of my favorite economists and political theorists. With the possible exception of a cousin who owns a tavern in Queens, I don’t think I know anyone who would fit a capitalist’s definition of a capitalist. But I watch Louis Rukeyser and keep up with Forbes and The Wall Street Journal, and agree with much of what I come across in those places about the efficiencies of the free-market system. That should count for something.

I make this disclaimer to assure the reader that I am not a closet socialist of some sort, seeking to undermine free-market capitalism in the name of Catholic social theory. If someone forced me to label my economic preferences, I would say that they are an uneven amalgam, still in the crucible, of Chesterbellocian notions and George Gilder’s work. (Yes, I know that presents some dilemmas.)

So I am not posturing when I say that my criticisms of certain modern defenders of the free market are meant to be constructive. I would like to see them become more effective in their attacks on the Big Government types. My fear, however, is that they are setting themselves up for a fall by resorting to overly glib anti-government clichés about the “private” character of wealth in this country.

I am thinking of the kinds of things you hear from Rush Limbaugh and see in the columns of economic libertarians like Walter Williams and Paul Craig Roberts. The line they seem to favor about people “feeding from the public trough” is one example.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! GET A FREE 7 DAY TRIAL

SUBSCRIBE TODAY

You May Also Enjoy

Making Sense of Papal Economics

A review of Papal Economics: The Catholic Church on Democratic Capitalism, from Rerum Novarum to Caritas in Veritate

Considering the Lilies of the Field

Jesus tells us to be anxious about others, and he promises that if we are anxious about others first, then we need not be anxious about ourselves, for all these things will be added unto us.

The Motherhood of the Church

If the priest were to overcome the counter-stigmata of the man with clean hands, and the Church go beyond almsgiving, the priest would have to roll up his sleeves and get dirty.