Volume > Issue > Note List > Totalitarianism or Anarchy?

Totalitarianism or Anarchy?

Last month in this section, we noted how Michael O’Brien, a novelist, contended in The Catholic World Report that same-sex “marriage” (and hate-crimes legislation) constitutes a “New Totalitarianism.” Now we learn from The Catholic World Report (Aug./Sept.) that “same-sex marriage leads to anarchy in family life” (it wouldn’t in the opposite-sex Catholic families we know), and will result in outright anarchy. We also learn that “Anarchy is the widespread rejection of established authority, or the refusal to accept that there are limits or boundaries that should not be transgressed. Anarchy need not arise because of a bloody revolution. It can result, less dramatically, from widespread acceptance of license…” So says Seana Sugrue, an Associate Professor of Politics at Ave Maria University in Naples, Fla.

So, what is it? A “New Totalitarianism” or “Anarchy”?

Sugrue says, “anarchy doesn’t last very long,” so she settles for what she calls a “soft despotism,” which is quite a ways from totalitarianism, which is a hard despotism.

Sugrue’s big point is that “marriage is a pre-political institution.” So what? So are polygamy, adultery, homosexuality, bestiality, rape, violence, theft, war, and so forth. They are all pre-political.

Enjoyed reading this?



You May Also Enjoy

The Wages of Motherhood

Viewed from the perspective of home and community, there's so much value attached to the work of stay-at-home mothers, that we've only just begun to count the cost of losing them to the workplace.

The Catholic Church After Obergefell

The U.S. Supreme Court’s recent and most unfortunate decision in Obergefell v. Hodges to legalize…

A Rosy Future for Same-Sex "Marriage"?

To be like ancient Rome, the U.S. in the 21st century has only to elect as its president a bachelor with same-sex partners and then to await plagues, invasions, and epidemics to hasten its decline and fall.