Love on Trial
NEW OXFORD NOTEBOOK
The coronavirus shutdowns put much of life on pause. They postponed weddings and baptisms, vacations and travel, and, in some locales, even home sales and evictions.
The shutdowns also put off a landmark canonical trial in the Episcopal Church.
Back in April of this year, William Love, Episcopal bishop of Albany, New York, was to present himself before a hearing panel for “failing to abide by the promises and vows made when he was ordained.”
What was Bishop Love’s canonical crime? Did he misappropriate money donated for charitable purposes or otherwise defraud the diocese? Did he deny the divinity of Christ or otherwise disparage the Creed? Did he carry on an extramarital affair or otherwise engage in sexual misconduct?
Nope. None of the above.
Bishop Love was to go on trial for refusing to allow same-sex marriage rites in his diocese.
At the Episcopal Church’s 79th General Convention in 2018, the House of Deputies and the House of Bishops, by a combined vote of 200 to eight (plus five “divided” votes), overwhelmingly approved Resolution B012, also known as Marriage Rites for the Whole Church. This “historic resolution,” the official Episcopal News Service gleefully reported, gives “all Episcopalians…full access to two trial-use marriage rites for same-sex and opposite-sex couples” so they can be “married by their priests in their home churches” (July 13, 2018).
And so, as of 2018, it was Bishop Love’s responsibility to make same-sex marriage rites available to his flock. That he would not do so constituted, in the eyes of his church, a violation of the vows he made at his ordination — in 1992.
You May Also Enjoy
The first victim of media vilification following the decision was Justice Antonin Scalia, who made clear that he thought the Court had overstepped its bounds and that the majority opinion "poses a threat to American democracy."
The recent history of the Anglican Communion shows that shedding virtually all of its distinctively Christian moral teachings in order to achieve "relevance" has disastrous results.
The Episcopal Church contorts its theology to conform to the broader culture, but the culture has no real use for a Christianity remade in its image.