Volume > Issue > The New-Generation Liberal Catholic: He'll Switch Rather Than Fight

The New-Generation Liberal Catholic: He’ll Switch Rather Than Fight


By David R. Carlin | October 1998
David R. Carlin is Associate Professor of Sociology and Philosophy at the Community College of Rhode Island.

When we run across Catholics eager to reform the Church in a “liberal” direction, many of us wonder: “Why do they bother? Why don’t they simply switch to some other church more to their taste?”

If, like the people in the European Middle Ages, we lived in a society in which Catholicism was the only religion, it would be easy to understand their combination of zeal for reform and antipathy to switching. After all, there would be no alternative churches to switch to. Hence it would be a case of either reforming the one and only church or putting up with a status quo they are deeply dissatisfied with.

But we Americans live in a land of phenomenal religious diversity. Not since the early centuries of the Roman empire has the world seen a society with so many religions — hundreds, if not thousands, of distinct religious groups. Most of these are varieties of Protestantism, which has proven itself capable of taking on more forms than Proteus. But one can also find Eastern Orthodoxy, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Native American religions, and others, and each of these comes in a number of varieties. Thus, for the dissatisfied Catholic, there is an immense menu of alternative religions to choose from.

This tremendous diversity is due in large measure to our nation’s Protestant heritage. From its beginning, Protestantism was founded on the principle of “private judgment” — the right of the individual to interpret Scripture for himself, or, more generally, the right of the individual to determine the content of his religious belief without depending on the judgment of the pope or any other religious authority.

Enjoyed reading this?



You May Also Enjoy

Love on Trial

The Episcopal Church contorts its theology to conform to the broader culture, but the culture has no real use for a Christianity remade in its image.

A Time to Pinch Ourselves

Yes, it’s really true. But no, there will be no gala banquet with a roster…

Briefly: October 2003

Reviews of Rethinking the Purpose of Business: Interdisciplinary Essays from the Catholic Social Tradition edited by S.A. Cortright and Michael J. Naughton... Back to the Drawing Board: The Future of the Pro-Life Movement edited by Teresa Wagner