Volume > Issue > The Guilty Secret of Liberal Christianity

The Guilty Secret of Liberal Christianity


By James Hitchcock | October 1996
James Hitchcock is Professor of History at St. Louis University. His latest book is the reissue of his The Recovery of the Sacred (reviewed in the March NOR).

Classical theories of secularization provide only limited understanding of religion in America, and that geographical deficiency in turn reveals the most important element lacking in most of those theories overall — a recognition of the primacy of cultural, and indeed religious, factors in the very process of religion’s decline.

In Western Europe secularization is closely related to industrialization, the classic pattern being pious peasants who, upon moving to the city, cease to practice their faith. That pattern has been traced roughly in proportion to the magnitude of urban centralization — large cities are more secular than small — and the size and complexity of the industrial enterprise itself.

Why this should be is not all that clear. Most obvious is the trauma of profound social displacement, as the familiar rural world, in which everything has its place and everything is taken for granted, dissolves into a wholly unfamiliar terrain where it seems nothing has its place. For many European industrial laborers, it was apparently simply a matter of having been raised in a religious environment in a rural village, then losing the habits of faith in the process of uprooting.

In many countries formal religion in the 19th century came to be identified with oppressive social structures. The self-respecting worker who was conscious of injustice, and believed that organized militancy was the only hope for improvement, came to regard the church as being in league with government and business in causing his oppression.

Enjoyed reading this?



You May Also Enjoy

The Dutch Are At It Again

The Dominicans in the Netherlands are agitating to open the priesthood to homosexuals, women, and married men.

Briefly: November 2013

The Secret Life of John Paul II... Manners in Modern Life: The Poetry of Conduct, the Virtue of Civility... Rebuilding Catholic Culture: How the Church Can Shape Our Common Life... Philosophical Virtues and Psychological Strengths

Briefly: June 1994

Reviews of Schooling Christians... Visions of Reality: What Funda­mentalist Schools Teach... Martyr of Brotherly Love...