Volume > Issue > Letter to the Editor: November 1989

November 1989

Timely, Factual

John C. Cort’s Septem­ber column, “Behind the Tempting Grape,” was one of the best and most timely pieces I’ve read in the NOR. He gave factual evidence on a topic which greatly needs publicity.

Among the many items in the NOR which I’ve greatly valued was Martin Young’s letter entitled “A Vietnam Veteran Responds to Fr. Fessio” (July-Aug.). His reply to Fessio was almost as good as the origi­nal column by Christopher Derrick which Fessio criti­cized.

Catharine Blankenship

Dunlap, California

A Jewish View

I guess I’m one of the few Jewish readers you have. I enjoy your articles and, although I do not accept Christianity, I do share and love the ethical teachings of Jesus, such as the Sermon on the Mount, and I admire the compassion Jesus showed for the poor, the aged, the ill, and the unfortunates of society.

One of the chief reasons I cannot accept Catholicism is your belief that Jesus was God. In our faith our major prayer is the Shm’a, or “Hear Oh Israel, the Lord the God, the Lord is One.” I also have great difficulty in believing Mary’s Immaculate Conception, as well as some of the miracles Jesus per­formed.

Some of my arguments with the Church go back to Pope Pius XII, who was silent as the proverbial sphinx while the terrible Holocaust was going on during the Second World War. I lost 45 relatives in concentration camps. Also, while acting as papal nuncio in Munich in the 1920s, he (then known as Eugenio Cardinal Pacelli) was very sympathetic to the Nazi cause and donated funds to the Nazi Party. How differ­ent that Pope was from the teachings of Jesus!

On the positive side, I (a Deist Jew) very much liked Pope John XXIII, who made every effort to liberalize the Church and to finally absolve the Jewish people of the “death of Jesus.” I admire the Catholic Church for its excellence in education and for the posture taken by the American bishops on so many social causes, especially the growing problems of poverty and homelessness. The Catholic Church leads all other churches on social issues. The Catholic Church has a tremendously good education system for children from kindergarten through high school. I admire the equality of dress which Catholic schools stipulate for girl students. I also pay my respects to the great American Catholic hospitals, where I have received merci­ful care from the sisters.

My major problem with the Church, or rather with the Vatican, is that it refuses to recognize the state of Israel. After all the suffering and agony of the Jewish people, the pope still refuses to admit that the Jewish people have a right to the land God willed to them.

Nevertheless, I very much enjoy the NOR. Keep up the good work!

Larry Chase

Upper Darby, Pennsylvania

Nose Against the Windowpane

I loved David Hartman’s article about his Protestant nose being on the Catholic windowpane (Sept.). My nose has been in that posi­tion for some time. The Rev. Hartman’s discussion was wonderfully balanced and sane, and it was just what I hoped for and needed.

More generally: the reviews by James J. Thomp­son Jr. are priceless. I have read many books because of his recommendation.

Loring Ellis

Hampton, South Carolina

You May Also Enjoy

The Richness of the Mongoloid Experience

My brother reacted with crazy love toward new people. He thought people’s differences made them wonderful.

New Oxford Notes: April 2009

The Self-Destruction of a Cult of Personality... Return Volley... U.S. Seminaries: Condition Stabilized...

Can You Imagine?

If Muslim women in India can protest condomania culture, why can't Catholics do the same thing in the United States of America?