Volume > Issue > Is Religious Belief a Type of Knowledge?

Is Religious Belief a Type of Knowledge?

ON THE PRESUMPTION OF NATURE’S INTELLIGIBILITY

By Thomas M. Lessl | April 2022
Thomas M. Lessl is Professor of Communication Studies at the University of Georgia. His scholarship examines scientific communication as it bears upon religion. He is the author of Rhetorical Darwinism: Religion, Evolution, and the Scientific Identity (Baylor University Press, 2012).

Nor do I seek to understand that I may believe, but I believe that I may understand. For this, too, I believe, that, unless I first believe, I shall not understand.St. Anselm

 

In our time, we have grown accustomed to thinking that religious claims, which we call “beliefs,” are the opposite of knowledge. In a game of free association, no one would likely respond to the word knowledge by saying “faith” or “belief.” They would more likely say “science,” “fact,” or “evidence.” We’re more likely to regard belief as an antonym for knowledge, and this is why many people regard religion and science as competitors and sometimes even enemies.

This attitude is a notable feature of what is often called modernism, a term that describes various cultural patterns that have developed over the past four centuries, that is, the modern or Enlightenment period. During this time (roughly 1600 to the present), people have become more literate, more secular, and more dependent on technology, urban ways of life, and science as a knowledge resource.

The growth of scientific understanding is the most impressive development that has occurred over these four centuries. Science has given the impression of making all things knowable, and with this comes the opposite notion that perhaps all things merely believed are expendable — religious beliefs in particular. If scientists can know things with certainty, why bother with things that are only speculative? The problem with this assumption is that it is a practical impossibility. There is no belief-independent knowledge, and in the following pages I will explain why this is so.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

...And Justice for Some

Catholic monuments, Catholic buildings, and Catholics themselves will continue to be attacked but the attackers have little to fear from the law.

The Soviet Union & Gorki’s God

A people, such as the Russians, who have produced and who still honor writers like Gorki, Dostoyevsky, and Tolstoy deserve to be regarded with respect.

The Mansour & Kosnik Cases

Under John Cardinal Dearden, the Archdio­cese of Detroit was one of the most famously “lib­eral”…