Volume > Issue > Is It Time to Elect Bishops Again?

Is It Time to Elect Bishops Again?


By Charles Molineaux | May 2005
Charles Molineaux is an attorney and freelance writer living in the Diocese of Arlington, Virginia. His articles and poetry have appeared in The Wall Street Journal, The Georgetown Academy, the Fellowship of Catholic Scholars Quarterly, and The Catholic Lawyer. The opinions expressed are those of the author alone and do not necessarily represent those of organizations of which he is a member.

Two developments of the past few years have caused American Catholics to focus on their largely unknown hierarchy — the televising of bishops’ meetings and the scandal of sexual abuse (by a small percentage of priests) with episcopal cover-up (by many bishops).

Thanks to television, particularly EWTN, we ordinary laity in the pews can look in on the bishops at their annual proceedings. Their names are becoming familiar and it’s not an impressive collection of shepherds. In the words of that inquiring mind, Butch Cassidy, we might dare ask, “Who are those guys?” Or, more importantly, where did they come from?

The second development — the abuse-and-cover-up scandal — makes those questions more urgent. Three years ago the panicked shepherds had to respond to the scandals and to appear, particularly to the media, to be doing something. And they did, producing the flawed Dallas Charter and appointing a National Review Board. The Dallas Charter was flawed because its focus was on the clergy and lay employees — somehow there was little mention of episcopal obstruction of justice. (One eager cardinal, oblivious to due process and concern for reputation, even released the names of all priests in his diocese ever accused of improprieties.)

How had it happened that a majority of bishops had priorities so disordered that, as summarized by the Dallas Morning News in 2002, they had sought to conceal and obstruct? Who picked them to lead the Church?

Enjoyed reading this?



You May Also Enjoy

Into the Void

One would think that retooling, remarketing, and simplifying the bishops' voting guide would be a priority aimed at enlarging its readership. Unfortunately, it is not.

Cardinal Cupich's Uncertain Trumpet

Revolution is an overturning of the present order; it is dreadful in any society. But it is impossible in the perfect society of the Holy Catholic Church.

The Shot Heard 'Round the World

When, on March 19, 1996, Bishop Fabian Bruskewitz of Lincoln, Nebraska, announced that Catholics in…