Volume > Issue > Another Outbreak of Mater, Si; Magistra, No

Another Outbreak of Mater, Si; Magistra, No

EDITORIAL

By Dale Vree | May 2006
Dale Vree is the Editor of New Oxford Review.

Mater, sí; Magístra, no means that she (the Church) is our Mother, but not our Teacher. Most Catholics make up their own minds about what they will or won’t accept in Church teachings — nowadays often called “pick-and-choose” Catholicism.

Regarding the statements by Pope John Paul II and Cardinal Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict XVI) that the war on Iraq is unjust, we’ve heard the same old “pick-and-choose” Catholicism from many of our readers who support the war. We’ve also heard persistently from some of our readers that those pronouncements are not infallible.

However, these pronouncements are not “prudential” judgments. These pronouncements have to do with doctrine and morals. War is precisely about morals.

As for doctrine, the Church has her Just War doctrine. One of the criteria for a just war is that it be a “last resort.” Only four days before the U.S. invaded Iraq, Pope John Paul II (once again) appealed to the Just War doctrine of “last resort,” adding that “there is still time to negotiate.”

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

Neither East nor West: On the Pope's Radical New Encyclical

When Pope John Paul II visited the U.S. last fall, we heard from liberal partisans…

Reflections on the Church Hierarchy

In February 2004 the NEW OXFORD REVIEW published an article of mine criticizing Archbishop…

Rome Under Siege

Over the last half-dozen years, the New Oxford Review has undergone some changes in emphasis.…