Volume > Issue > Note List > An Inexplicable Apology

An Inexplicable Apology

Good writers are like painters. They paint captivating pictures with mere words — colorful pictures with only black ink. Case in point: In his column in Our Sunday Visitor (Nov. 11, 2001), J.F. Pisani tells us about a 50th wedding anniversary party he and his wife attended at a restaurant: “I sat at a table with two older couples and several elderly women, whom I assumed were aunts of the family. It seems that unmarried or widowed aunts populate these family events, like matriarchs in search of a royal court. They’re always offering advice and telling their nieces and nephews how to live….” In your mind’s eye, you see the picture — especially if you’ve been there, done that. That phrase, “like matriarchs in search of a royal court,” is masterful; it speaks a thousand snapshots, and more (and excuses his use of “whom” when it should be “who”).

Pisani continues: “I was reasonably sure that, before the night was over, I would have to ask an aunt or two to dance as part of my social responsibility — or as a corporal work of mercy.” Ah, just so.

Now, that’s good writing — evocative and delightfully amusing. And honest.

But then comes the December 9 Our Sunday Visitor with a scolding letter from Jacqueline Osowski: “Shame on you, J.F. Pisani, for the chauvinistic and uncharitable remarks you wrote….” Osowski is leveling an ad hominem attack here, for she doesn’t bother to attempt refuting anything Pisani said, but is only maligning his character.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

Briefly: May 1994

Reviews of Death Foretold: The Jesuit Mur­ders in El Salvador... Peace or Armageddon? The Un­folding of the Middle East Peace Accord... Making Men Moral: Civil Liber­ties and Public Morality... Black Dogs... Against the Heresies... The Concise Dictionary of Early Christianity... Pro-Life Activist's Encyclopedia...

Halloween Unmasked

On November 2, 1997, I was walking to a bus stop after shopping at the…

Fed Up With Being a Rat In a Liturgical Lab

Tolkien’s The Hobbit or There and Back Again is the quintessential quest story. Familiar places…