American Catholics: Unclear on the Concepts
Are American Catholics dense?
That seemed, at first blush, to be the underlying message delivered this January by Peter Kodwo Appiah Cardinal Turkson, president of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace. In the lead-up to the Catholic Social Ministry Gathering in Washington, D.C., where he was to give the plenary address, the Ghanaian cardinal had some interesting things to say about the way American Catholics read papal documents.
He has been surprised, he said, that common theological terms are often misunderstood or misinterpreted stateside. “We found out that some of the vocabulary which is just taken for granted and used freely [in the Vatican] may not always have the same sense or may have had some nuances which sometimes are missed because of the way the terms are used in the American political context,” he said in an interview with Catholic News Agency (Jan. 13).
This peculiar problem became particularly acute after Pope Benedict XVI issued Caritas in Veritate, his 2009 encyclical outlining the Church’s vision for “integral human development” in economics, society, and politics through the principles of charity and truth. (The Pope appointed Cardinal Turkson to his present post a few months after the encyclical’s release; the cardinal’s primary task is to promote the Church’s social teaching worldwide, with special emphasis on Caritas in Veritate.) Cardinal Turkson said that although the Vatican was generally pleased with the response to the encyclical, reaction from some sectors of the American audience was “unexpected.” The cardinal emphasized that this is not a general or widespread problem. But, he said, “in certain circles…there is a difficulty.”
Which circles might those be? We can venture a guess based on the terms Cardinal Turkson specified as being among the ones that are often misunderstood. These include “social justice,” which he said is often mistakenly connected to socialism; “solidarity,” which is mistakenly linked to communist regimes (this one’s a real head-scratcher considering that “Solidarity” was an anti-communist Polish movement led by the Catholic Lech Walesa); and “gift,” which is perceived as encouraging welfare handouts.
Enjoyed reading this?
READ MORE! REGISTER TODAYSUBSCRIBE
You May Also Enjoy
Review of Catholic Social Teaching: An Historical Perspective by Roger Aubert, edited by David A. Boileau
Were any of us twenty-first-century Catholics to be transported back in time to an earlier…
Are American Catholics dense? That seemed, at first blush, to be the underlying message delivered by Peter Kodwo Appiah Cardinal Turkson.