Volume > Issue > Why the Music Is So Bad

Why the Music Is So Bad


By Lucy E. Carroll | October 2008
Lucy E. Carroll writes frequently on sacred music for Ado­re­mus Bulletin (www.Adoremus.org). Her Churchmouse Squeaks cartoons appear in the Adoremus print edition. She is currently organist/director at the Carmelite Monastery in Philadelphia, and Adjunct Associate Professor of Music Education at Westminster Choir College of Rider University in Princeton, New Jersey.

There has been an increasing groundswell of complaint lately about the inadequacies of music for the Novus Ordo Mass — the primitive quality of the music, the inappropriateness of style, the lack of sacred nature, and the near-heretical status of many hymn texts. A generation has grown up never hearing Latin, chant, polyphony, or traditional hymns in church. Much of this has been blamed on the Second Vatican Council. The Council, however, re-affirmed the use of Latin as the official language of the Roman rite, extolled the value of choir, stated that chant was to be given “pride of place,” and urged that musicians be well trained in seminaries and parishes. Pope John XXIII, who convened the Council, wrote an encyclical, Veterum Sapientia (1962), stressing the importance of Latin training in seminaries.

Pope Benedict XVI’s recent visit to the U.S. brought the great variance in “Catholic” music to the mainstream media. The music in the papal Mass in New York City, with its use of classical composers –Schubert, Brahms, Mozart, Palestrina — and chant, was in stark contrast to the pop-style hymns, merengue rhythms, and secular styles of music in the papal Mass in Washington, D.C. Indeed, during the D.C. Mass, EWTN’s Raymond Arroyo stated on the air that this was unusual music to choose for this Pope. He further added that Pope Benedict had written much about the liturgy and its music, and that it was evident that the people who selected the music for this Mass had not read a word of it. Commentators on other networks, however, repeated the press release they had been given that this Mass showcased “American multiculturalism.”

Why the discrepancy between the instruction and the practice?

There is the oft-repeated concern that, instead of reading the actual Vatican documents, Church leaders look to so-called experts who propound “the spirit of Vatican II,” which has little to do with the actual writings. But the problems run much deeper.

Enjoyed reading this?



You May Also Enjoy

Offering Our Musical Best at Mass

Parishes should be taught, preferably by example, that music is not by nature a democratic art and that musical values — like doctrines — are not subject to vote.

Does Good Liturgy Beget Moral Virtue?

Good liturgy involves good taste, and, as Burke said, taste depends on rational judgment, emotional maturity, and education — that is to say, the virtues.

Revised Musical Settings for the Revised Missal?

Although the secular culture has moved on, a slew of folksy, pop-style hymns and Mass music still remains in most parishes.