Volume > Issue > Note List > We Think We're Making a Difference

We Think We’re Making a Difference

Just one example: In our New Oxford Note “Automatic Forgiveness” (Sept. 2005), we took Fr. Ron Rolheiser to task, a theologian and an award-winning author.

In his column in Catholic San Francisco (April 22, 2005), Fr. Rolheiser said: “We have a doctrine within our faith, which to my mind is singularly the most consoling belief in all religion, namely, the belief that Christ can descend into hell…. Jesus ‘descended into hell.’ What does this mean?… The sin of Adam and Eve closed the gates of heaven and they remained sealed until the death of Jesus. Jesus’ death opened them and Jesus, himself, in the time between his death and resurrection, descended into hell (Sheol, the Underworld) where all the souls who had died since the time of Adam somehow rested. He took them all to heaven.”

We noted in our New Oxford Note that the Catechism (#633) does not say that Jesus took them all to Heaven. It says that Jesus took “the just” to Heaven.

He returns to the theme in Catholic San Francisco (Jan. 19, 2007): “after Jesus died, in that time between Good Friday and Easter Sunday, he went to the underworld where all the good people who had died since the time of Adam and Eve waited and he opened for them the gates of paradise” (italics added). Well, well.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

The Invisible Man

The novel's anonymous observer finds all of us flawed, but there are good moments that befall him — he meets individuals who have acquired an earned wisdom about life.

Conspicuous Consumption & the Falling Rate of Enjoyment

Given an absence of time for imagining alternatives, our humanity is defined in terms of consumption. We lack the peace needed to cultivate ourselves as unique persons.

A Last Conversation with Anna Freud

Several times in these columns I have mentioned Anna Freud, who did so very much…