Volume > Issue > Unintelligible Profundities & Intelligible Muddles

Unintelligible Profundities & Intelligible Muddles

WHY DO 'THE BEST & THE BRIGHTEST' FALL FOR THEM?

By John C. Cort | November 1998
John C. Cort is author of Christian Socialism: An Informal History.

One of our most respected moralists, Alasdair MacIntyre, has lamented that there is “no rational way of securing moral agreement in our culture.” Why this moral breakdown?

One place to look for the answer is in the books of the more fashionable philosophers of the 20th century, men whose names are dropped with pride and whose sayings are quoted with respect in our institutions of higher learning, including some institutions of the Catholic persuasion.

Granted, the modern philosopher’s lot is not a happy one. Alfred North Whitehead once said that Western philosophy is all footnotes to Plato. An exaggeration, but true to this extent: Many of the interesting things were written long ago. In recent times there has been less and less room for originality.

Faced with this dilemma, many philosophers, starting about the time of Hegel in the early 19th century, have resorted to what A.O. Lovejoy calls “unintelligible profundity.” I have been working on a book that involves the intellectual history of the idea of justice, which has compelled me to read some of today’s fashionable philosophers, writers such as the German Martin Heidegger, the Frenchmen Jean-Paul Sartre and Jacques Derrida, and the Lithuanian-Frenchman Emmanuel Levinas.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

Newman, an “Apostate”?

Arthur Schlesinger said "the most luxuriant, tenacious tradition of paranoic agitation in American history has been anti-Catholicism." This book is the product of it.

Building a Fine Fire in the Fireplace

The fireplace without the fire is empty ritual and mere churchianity. The fire without the fireplace is chaos and hairsplitting and division.

Berkeley Professor Wants More Catholics to Get Divorced

America magazine is unhappy with Catholic teaching on "remarriage."