Volume > Issue > Two Special Friends of God

Two Special Friends of God

Convergences: To the Source of Christian Mystery

By Hans Urs von Balthasar

Publisher: Ignatius Press

Pages: 153

Price: $8.95

Review Author: Thomas W. Case

Thomas W. Case is a poet, writer, and doctoral student at the Dominican School of the Graduate Theological Union in Berkeley. His writings have appeared in City Lights Journal, the San Francisco Chronicle, and elsewhere.

Also reviewed:

The Gates of Eternal Life. By Adrienne von Speyr. Ignatius Press. 140 pages. $7.95.


A priest I much admire said recently that Hans Urs von Balthasar is probably the greatest theologian since St. Thomas Aquinas. I would add that his spiritual companion and helpmate Adri­enne von Speyr is perhaps the greatest of contem­porary mystics. In tandem or alone, each is a spe­cial friend of God. Von Balthasar was influential in Adrienne’s conversion to the Catholic faith; he was her lifelong confessor; he acted as secretary and ed­itor of her “dictations”; and her “dictations” pro­foundly influenced his theology.

Von Balthasar’s Convergences is actually a collection of five essays, related by the single theme which is the title of the book — the “conver­gence to the source” of the disparate outpourings of the heart and the mind in the study of God. For human nature is at least superficially divided be­tween these two organs of reception (what the heart dictates, the mind often disallows, and vice versa); only on a deeper level and only sometimes in the history of Christian spirituality have the mind and heart been as one, congruent to the source of the supernal mystery. This is the constant struggle of mankind, not just for theologians, and the struggle and its resolution are most cogently portrayed in the little essay near the end of the book called “The Unity of Our Lives.” Here the fo­cus is directly on the present-day Christian con­fronted by and making his way through this world on his way to eternal life.

The first part of the book is harder going for the not-so-well informed. The first two essays are a highly original and insightful, but also highly con­centrated, journey up through the ages; and they assume on the part of the reader at least some fa­miliarity with great Church figures of the past — from Origen to St. Bernard to St. Bonaventure to St. Thomas. A passing knowledge of modern phil­osophy would also help. In truth the book is not so much a detailed exposition as a kind of concise wrap-up of things long pondered by the author.

Lest these remarks be off-putting, let me say that the struggle to understand is well worth the ef­fort. There is nothing arid or inconsequential in this man’s writing. And he is never dull. Just to whet your appetite:

Today the Christian people (or what is left of it) is searching with a lamp for persons who radiate something of the light, something of nearness to the source. It has long since had enough of the modernities, lacking all religious in­stinct, which trumpet at it from the press, the radio, and often enough from the pulpit. It is sad because it is untended, and an all too justified fear torments it that the “one thing necessary” could be totally blocked off by the “experts,” or the many dilettantes and apostates who pose as such. Often these are poor wretches, who must shout so loud in or­der to justify to themselves their inner predicament of no longer being able to pray.

There is less to say about Adrienne von Speyr’s book The Gates of Eternal Life because I feel less able to say it. I don’t know to what extent her “dictations” are inspired — in the strict theo­logical sense of the term — but I must confess that as soon as I started reading the book, a kind of shift occurred in me that sometimes happens when I read the Bible, and sometimes when I read some of the saints. It is a shift in perception that means to me that I am in the presence of something — or someone — Authoritative. When this happens to me I feel like 99 percent of all the books ever writ­ten should be thrown out, and these few that re­main be read, and reread, and read again.

But what is the book about? Well, she talks a lot about “perishable time” and “eternal time.” “Our time,” she says, “always limps far behind eternal time.” It is as if Adrienne were standing mostly in Heaven, and speaking of the earth from the standpoint of heaven rather than speaking of Heaven from the standpoint of earth.

And from this reversed perspective, she can say — about prayer, for example — “its direction is not toward eternity, but from eternity, a participa­tion in the journey of the Son from heaven to earth.”

I have never before heard anything like that. The whole book is like that, unfamiliar but some­thing you find yourself continually saying “yes, yes” to. I say buy the book, and read it, and read it again.


©1985 New Oxford Review. All Rights Reserved.

Enjoyed reading this?



You May Also Enjoy

The Dubious Adrienne von Speyr

Perhaps tied to old memories from her pre-Catholic youth, Speyr's private revelations seem to conflict with Catholic teaching on vital points.

Two Special Friends of God

Von Balthasar was influential in Adrienne von Speyr’s conversion; he was her confessor, secretary and ed­itor of her “dictations”; and her “dictations” pro­foundly influenced his theology.

The Variety & Theological Implications of Private Revelations

Evil spirits, often in a very subtle manner, have been far more clever and more destructive of sound spiritual thinking than generally supposed.