Volume > Issue > The Conversion of Ruth Snyder

The Conversion of Ruth Snyder

A MYSTERY OF HISTORY

By James K. Hanna | March 2022
James K. Hanna is an online instructor for Notre Dame’s Satellite Theology Education Program and a freelance writer who has been published in Our Sunday Visitor Newsweekly, Gathered Fragments, and Marian Studies.

Ruth Snyder and her adulterous lover, Judd Gray, were convicted of murdering Ruth’s husband, Albert Snyder, while he was passed out, drunk on bootleg whiskey. Sentenced to death, they were executed minutes apart in the Sing Sing electric chair on January 12, 1928.

The pair and their crime garnered national attention, but it was Ruth’s story that captivated the public. New York’s Daily News reported, “The woman who commands, in one manner or another, the attention of the nation is Ruth Snyder, who stood by and urged her paramour, Judd Gray, to beat to death her art-editor husband with a sash-weight. The courts said she shall die for the brutal, premeditated and conceived-in-love-lust slaying” (Nov. 23, 1927).

There is more: Only weeks prior to the murder, Ruth had duped her husband into increasing his life insurance. For additional sensation, consider that her lover was a corset salesman who was also married.

The torrid affair and its aftermath have been the subject of stage productions and true-crime accounts, including historian Landis MacKellar’s The Double-Indemnity Murder: Ruth Snyder, Judd Gray, and New York’s Crime of the Century (2006), and served as the inspiration for Ron Hansen’s novel A Wild Surge of Guilty Passion (2011).

What stands out in the present is a question asked at the time, but one history has abandoned. Ruth Snyder, baptized a Lutheran, entered prison as a nonbeliever but died less than a year later as a Roman Catholic. Was her conversion sincere, or was it merely a ploy to obtain the sympathy of the only person with the power to stay her execution, New York Governor Al Smith, himself a Catholic?

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

Not-So-Blessed Martin

Converts from Lutheranism show how recognition that Luther's understanding and actions were flawed is certainly not an easy transition.

Why a Self-Indulgent Age Needs a Rough Religion

Penance is man’s pitiful part in cooperation with grace, an extreme method necessary to combat the difficulties posed by the passion and the pride of man.

The Extraordinary Ordinariate

In England, with the establishment of the or­dinariate, the effects of Pope Benedict's 2010 visit would be felt in concrete ways for years to come.