Volume > Issue > Note List > Rushing to Judgment (To Understate It)

Rushing to Judgment (To Understate It)

We expected that our June article on “Scott Hahn’s Novelties” by Edward O’Neill, critiquing Dr. Hahn, would elicit many irate knee-jerk responses. And it has.

We award First Prize for Pavlovian Responses to Mark Shea, as it appeared on his personal weblog (June 24). Shea says that the NEW OXFORD REVIEW and O’Neill “stabbed a brother in Christ,” and that O’Neill’s article was “a fifteen page work of character assassination.”

Character assassination? If you did read O’Neill’s article, you’d be as astounded as we were. (Indeed, Dr. Hahn replies in this NOR’s letters section, “to clarify a few misimpressions,” but also saying, “I could not hope for kinder words to be spoken of me than those he used at the beginning and end of his article,” and “O’Neill has done me a great kindness in paying close attention to a few of my works.”)

We wondered if Shea even bothered to read O’Neill’s article. We say that not only because the article wasn’t 15 pages (it was 12 pages), but because Shea almost admits he didn’t read the article. Says he: “There’s a reason I no longer read NOR. Who needs this kind of destructive bomb-throwing shit?” (Sorry, but you should see the full obscenity of what he wrote.)

If Shea no longer reads the NOR, did he read the article (it has not been posted on our website)? Apparently not, for Shea mentions absolutely nothing in O’Neill’s article.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

Cohabitation: Ten Facts

Este artículo: en español

“Cohabitation — it’s training for divorce.” — Chuck Colson (1995)…

Briefly: May 2009

Review of Catholic Manual of Civility... Darwin's Plantation: Evolution's Racist Roots... Understanding Our Being: An Introduction to Speculative Philosophy in the Perennial Tradition...

Embarrassing & Contradictory

In Catholic doctrine, God gives us free will, so we can repent or not. Kendall gets free will and predestination mixed up. Embarrassing!