Religious Freedom: What Is the Catholic Teaching?
RECONCILIATION OF OLD AND NEW?
I was pleased to find in the October 1998 NEW OXFORD REVIEW an article entitled “Why Vatican II’s Declaration on Religious Liberty Does Not Violate Catholic Tradition” by Andrew Tardiff, for the conciliar teaching and traditional Catholic teaching seem to be in conflict, and I would like to be persuaded that the conflict is resolvable. Tardiff’s article didn’t persuade me.
The issues are as follows: The traditional teaching is that in a Catholic society the state may prohibit public worship by non-Catholic religions, the publication of heretical books, the public teaching of heresy, and other public actions that threaten the faith and salvation of the citizens. (For brevity, I will use the phrase “public teaching of error” or “public expression of error” to cover all these types of action.) The Vatican II document Dignitatis Humanae (DH) appears to reverse this teaching.
The Vatican Council declares that the human person has a right to religious freedom. Freedom of this kind means that all men should be immune from coercion on the part of individuals, social groups and every human power so that, within due limits, nobody is forced to act against his convictions in religious matters in private or in public, alone or in associations with others (n. 2, emphasis added).
It states that human dignity requires that people be able to express publicly those religious beliefs that they sincerely hold, whatever the orthodoxy of those beliefs.
You May Also Enjoy
Gut-Wrenching... Don’t Tune Out a Much-Needed Voice... A Turn in Every Direction... Misunderstanding Humanae Vitae... Counteracting Suicidal Ideation... Very Wrong... The Nuptial Meaning of the Body... Surmounting a Wall-Building Ecclesiology
How to Eliminate the Poor... You Can Criticize Bad Bishops, But Don't You Dare Criticize the Pope Who Appointed Them... Wise Advice From a Vocations Director... What's Good for the Corporations Is Good for America... Wily Guys... A New Catholic Community... The Beat Goes On... In Vitro Clinics Are Death Camps... A Pox On Both Your Houses... "Relevant Public Authorities"?...
Abstraction is the most reliable vehicle of evil; it allows us to lie with a straight face, to mask our corruption with benumbing slogans empty of substance.