Volume > Issue > Note List > If It's Good for the Goose…

If It’s Good for the Goose…

Brother Jack Talbot, a member of the Capuchin Province of St. Joseph (headquartered in Detroit), wants the readers of the National Catholic Reporter to know that he’s “out of the closet” as a “gay friar” (column, May 17). Since few of our readers take the Reporter, and since Br. Jack wants the world to know, we thought we’d pass along the news.

Jack makes reference to what a friend, also a “gay” religious brother, worriedly calls “the Vatican’s recent attack on homosexuals in religious life.” But Jack — champion of Truth, Justice, and the American Way — lets us know that he will not go back into the closet or disavow the “gay” label he’s pinned on himself. So there, take that, you Vatican pigs!

Jack doesn’t tell us whether or not he’s celibate. The closest he comes to addressing that question is to quote the same “gay” brother, “We can be celibate but still be characterized as sexual deviants” (indeed! that’s what the Church teaches in so many words, but the brother says that’s “a lie”). But the $64,000 question is not “can you be celibate?” but “are you celibate?”

Jack himself adds that “in my own experience, especially in religious life, there is a presumption that if one is out, one is sexually active,” adding that this is “unhelpful” though “a widely held belief.”

“Unhelpful”? What does that mean? But yes, it’s a widely held belief. Absolutely so.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

A Manufactured Controversy

Those raising the most vocal objections to new diocesan teacher contracts -- which stipulate that teachers conduct themselves according to basic Catholic principles in their public lives -- are those who do not agree with many of the Church's teachings.

Sore Losers

Whenever gay-rights groups are challenged democratically and lose, they complain of being victims of entrenched bigots. November's elections provide some excellent examples.

What Would Flannery O'Connor Say?

Years ago, I was having coffee with some good friends, Catholic mothers just like me,…