Cafeteria Catholicism & the Pope’s Encyclical
CHRIST & NEIGHBOR
On a recent “Firing Line” program, William F. Buckley Jr. hosted Michael Novak and Fr. Richard McBrien in a discussion of John Paul II’s latest bombshell, a discussion that revealed some interesting things about “cafeteria Catholicism.”
The bombshell was the Pope’s encyclical Sollicitudo Rei Socialis, which he wrote to commemorate the 20th anniversary of another papal bombshell, Populorum Progressio of Paul VI. The latter was newsworthy, even revolutionary, for several reasons: One, it expressed more clearly and forcefully than other statements the foundation stone of Judeo-Christian social teaching: “No one is justified in keeping for his exclusive use what he does not need when others lack necessities.” I prefix “Christian” with “Judeo” because this principle of social justice goes back not only to Aquinas, the Fathers of the Church, and Jesus, but to the Prophets and sages of the Old Testament.
Two, for the first time Populorum Progressio, clearly extended this obligation from individuals to nations: “The superfluous wealth of rich countries should be placed at the service of poor nations.”
Three, for the first time in a modern papal document, the Thomistic teaching on just revolution was expressed, namely, that “a revolutionary uprising” could be justified “where there is manifest, long-standing tyranny which would do great damage to fundamental personal rights and dangerous harm to the common good of the country.”
You May Also Enjoy
Michael Harrington was an eloquent, attractive leader and lucid thinker. Even those who disagreed with him found it almost impossible not to love him.
Morality based on the opening of the soul expressed by the prophets of Israel, the mystic philosophers of Greece, and the authors of the Gospels defies all calculations of self-interest and promises joy.
In June Pope John Paul II visited his beloved Poland. While it had been thought…