Volume > Issue > Note List > A Time Out for Time Magazine

A Time Out for Time Magazine

When Time magazine does a feature piece on the Catholic Church, don’t think for a minute, dear reader, that Time is on our side. Take, for example, David Van Biema’s article on the beatification of Pope Pius IX (Sept. 4): Whom should Van Biema marshal in his contrived debate on Pio Nono but none other than Garry Wills (of Papal Sin infamy) — this in an attempt to heap ridicule on one of the Church’s most steadfast defenders.

Van Biema paints, as best he can, Pio Nono as an out-of-control megalomaniac who invented the doctrine of Papal Infallibility in order to shut up his Modernist opponents. Taking Pio Nono out of his historical context, Van Biema derides his methods and character. In delivering the obligatory aspersions of anti-Semitism, Van Biema doesn’t seem to realize that the mission of the Church is to evangelize and that Jesus — who was not known for His soft hand — got it all started by evangelizing the Jews first. If that qualifies as anti-Semitism, then by Van Biema’s measure, the Messiah is a bigot and none of the Apostles would qualify for sainthood.

Van Biema’s polemic can be summed up in one quote: “He was truly pious. However, he was also…bullying.” Loosely translated: “Yeah, he was a goody-two-shoes, but sometimes he was really mean!” Come on, Van Biema, grow up! You’re not in kindergarten anymore and this isn’t a contest to see who gets to be kickball monitor. For your tantrum, you and your pouty, thumb-sucking friends deserve a time out.

Enjoyed reading this?



You May Also Enjoy

Letter to the Editor: April 2018

Fear Not the Peddlers of Error... Dreams of Robot Love... A Tough Transition... Bull's Eye... The Comeback Is Here... Trump & Abortion: Guarded Optimism... Arguable Assertions... I Have Not Been "Played"... A Way Forward... A Jurist for All Seasons... Desiring the Death of Those They Should Love... and more

Number One in Spirituality?

I'm Fr. Tops, the best spiritual director in America. (No confessions, please.)

New Oxford Notes: September 2011

Avoiding Guilt by Association... The Luxury of Religious Fanaticism... When Sectarian Violence Is Genocide... Unlearning Compassion in San Diego