A Response From Jean Bethke Elshtain
Neither simple agreement nor disagreement seems the best course in responding to Hanink’s eloquent articulation of “A Personalist Vision.” Instead, I shall pick up on several themes that seem to be particularly compelling from the standpoint of political and civic philosophy in and for our time.
(1) Hanink helps us read the “signs of the times” in caring and discerning ways. The personalist vision constitutes a provocative critique of much of modernity. This vision does not fit tidily into our by now facile labels of “left/right, progressive/ regressive.” Instead, personalism makes such labels problematic and jogs our thinking in other directions by insisting that we focus on what Hanink refers to as our “established disorder,” whether evident in disregard for vulnerable human existence at the beginning or the end of the life cycle, or in relentless fashioning of weapons of mass destruction.
(2) The personalist construction of “human rights” offers a powerful alternative to a starkly individualistic or possessive construal of rights, without abandoning the language of rights altogether. That is, we are seen to have rights as members of communities. We are parts of a greater whole with a duty to consider the good of others and not to wallow exclusively in self-interest. However, the social good or purpose does not override the unique value of each individual. Individuals have a unique and independent “finality” (in the words of John Paul II) that must not be overridden by society.
Rights here become one constitutive feature of a notion of public or social freedom.
You May Also Enjoy
Reviews of A Nation Under Lawyers... The Philosopher and the Provocateur. The Correspondence of Jacques Maritain and Saul Alinsky Lead, Kindly Light: My Journey to Rome... The Oxford Companion to the Bible... The Catholics of Harvard Square... How to Read the Apocalypse... Reckoning with Apocalypse: Terminal Politics and Christian Hope... Catholic Schools and the Common Good... Devoutly I Adore Thee: The Prayers and Hymns of St. Thomas Aquinas... Chapters into Verse: Poetry in English Inspired by the Bible... Theology and Sanity...
Girls in the ghetto are hungry for love, and desperately afraid of not going along with the social, cultural, and sexual pressures of the street.
Reviews of No Place for Truth: Or Whatever Happened to Evangelical Theology?... A Theology of Word and Spirit... Revisioning Evangelical Theology...