“The Real Post-Conciliar Reforms”?
In a New Oxford Note about Vatican II titled “It Ain’t Broke, But Let’s Fix It Anyhow” (June 2004), we said: “We’d dearly like to know why it [Vatican II] was [necessary]. We can think of a few things that Vatican II did that were good and necessary — but only a few….” We then asked if anyone would like to submit a manuscript to the NOR on why Vatican II was good and necessary. In this issue, we are printing an article by John Lamont on why Vatican II was a good thing, though not a necessary thing.
Lamont’s article got us to thinking again about Vatican II and its possible achievements. In this regard, we delved into our files and came up with an article by James Hitchcock called “The Real Post-Conciliar Reforms” in Catholic Dossier (Nov.-Dec. 1997), which was published by Ignatius Press and is now defunct.
Says Hitchcock: “Given the devastation which is now apparent on all sides, it is easy to think of the pre-conciliar Church as a sinless paradise and all change as having been for the worse. But genuinely hopeful signs in the contemporary Church can best be seen by recognizing real abuses which existed in the pre-conciliar Church.” He then ticks off seven achievements of Vatican II.
You May Also Enjoy
The Mosque Underwear Riot... Naked, and Ye Caused an Accident... Roadway Radiation Repair... My Two Wives... June Is So Gay... Ending Gender-Bending... Return Then, Most Gracious Advocate - Redux... Scum of the Eart, the Church... Conversions of Convenience
In Jesus' warning to the women of Jerusalem, He says that those who wish for barrenness will also "say to the mountains: Fall on us; and to the hills: Cover us."
The Old & New Guard... Limbo: An Enigma... What is the Life of an Unborn Baby Worth... The Target of Evil... Prayer in Adoration... The Pleasure of Kalpakgian... How to Kick the Bad Music Habit... Medjugorje Contradictions... Why Jesus Ordained Only Men... Three Marys... Traditional Catholic Resources... and more