The Mansour & Kosnik Cases
VATICAN WATCH
Under John Cardinal Dearden, the Archdiocese of Detroit was one of the most famously “liberal” dioceses in the U.S., a center of dissent from official Catholic teaching. This past spring, the Vatican (which had appointed a new archbishop three years ago) started reining in on some of the most blatant abuses.
Sister Agnes Mary Mansour was a nun who ran unsuccessfully for Congress (favoring legalized and publicly funded abortions), then was named director of social services for the state of Michigan. The latter post requires her to administer state funding of abortions.
Sr. Agnes went through the ritual motion of insisting that, “Personally I am opposed to abortion, but….” However, she apparently sees no contradiction between her stated moral position and the fact that she is now responsible for paying for the deaths of numerous unborn children every year. (In doing so she is also, arguably, thwarting the will of the people of Michigan. The legislature has cut off this funding several times, only to be vetoed by the governor.)
Archbishop Edmund Szoka of Detroit at first seemed to minimize the importance of the controversy, but then told Sr. Agnes she would have to make clear her own opposition to abortion funding. When she failed to do this, he ordered her to resign her post, and she refused.
You May Also Enjoy
“I didn’t know Christians would help me,” the expectant mother told the counselor. “I thought they were all mean.”
Charlotte Allen has made the provocative assertion that the project of Catholic dissent has "lost steam as an intellectual movement."
Margaret Sanger worked to overturn the laws against obscenity, birth control, and abortion mainly because her secret lifestyle made all these things necessary.