Volume > Issue > South Africa's Catholic Bishops: Going Down the Anglican Road

South Africa’s Catholic Bishops: Going Down the Anglican Road

GUEST BOOK

By Joanne Sadler Butler | June 1998
Joanne Sadler Butler is an economist in Washington, D.C.

In his book review in the April NOR, Dale Vree asked rhetorically, “Who is God really? Father or Mother?” “Apparently,” said Vree in commenting with disapproval on the views of a prominent theologian, “it depends on where you happen to be at a particular moment….”

My question is: Does the Catholic Church really recognize the Holy Eucharist as the true Body and Blood of Christ? Apparently it depends on where you happen to live. In most places in the world, even the U.S., the answer (at least officially) is “yes,” the bread and wine are transubstantiated into the Body and Blood of Jesus Christ. But in South Africa, the answer seems to be “no” or “maybe” or “not always.”

The reason things are different in South Africa is that their bishops have been drifting toward an Anglican approach to Holy Communion: As long as you’re a baptized Christian, you may receive the wafer and the wine, and believe what you like about them. The Southern African Bishops’ Conference’s January 1998 Directory on Ecumenism states that if non-Catholic Christians are attending Mass for “a special feast or event” they may take Holy Communion, as doing so “may be both meaningful and desirable, expressing the degree of unity that the participating Christians already have with each other.”

With that kind of belief, the Body and Blood of Christ are reduced to a treat, to be handed out indiscriminately at weddings, funerals, baptisms — or to be given to a Protestant U.S. President when he happens to be in the congregation.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! GET A FREE 7 DAY TRIAL

SUBSCRIBE TODAY

You May Also Enjoy

Cardinal Cupich's Uncertain Trumpet

Revolution is an overturning of the present order; it is dreadful in any society. But it is impossible in the perfect society of the Holy Catholic Church.

Episcopal Fundamentalism In the Catholic Church

Let's face it. Many Catholic bishops today don't want interference from the Holy See.

Some Questions for the American Bishops

Your Excellencies:

Many of your people are concerned about where our beloved Church is, and…