Volume > Issue > Reclaiming Jonathan Edwards for Political Progressivism

Reclaiming Jonathan Edwards for Political Progressivism


By Michael Nelson | October 1988
Michael Nelson is Associate Professor of Political Science at Vanderbilt University. A former editor of The Washington Monthly, his articles have appeared in the Journal of Poli­tics and Harvard Business Review, among others. His books include Presidents, Politics, and Policy (with Erwin C. Har­grove) and Presidential Selection (with Alexander Heard). He is a political analyst for WSMV-TV in Nashville.

Am I alone in having grown up with this image of Jonathan Edwards? — a wrathful Puritan, preach­ing a narrow, intellectually primitive Calvinism, smugly assuming his own place in the ranks of God’s predestined elect, with eternal damnation awaiting most of his parishioners, even as he insist­ed that they toe the rigid moral line in the here and now; still worse, a man of privilege and status who, to justify the social order of his day, blithely equated New England Puritans with God’s new Chosen People, thus advancing a doctrine that led, in the short run, to vile treatment of the Indians and, permanently, to a morally arrogant messianic strain in American foreign policy.

Certainly that is the image of Edwards the scholarly community has sustained through most of this century. Literary critics and progressive historians such as Carl Van Doren and Vernon L. Parrington have tended to dismiss him as irrelevant to our day or even to his own. The epilogue to Henry B. Parkes’s 1930 book, The Fiery Puritan, charges, for example, that “if Edwards had never lived, there would be today no blue laws, no societies for the suppression of vice, no Volstead Act.”

In truth, Edwards’s life and thought were vastly different from the caricature. He was a man of the establishment, yes, but one who defied and was brought down by the establishment, both ec­clesiastical and financial. He was a man of religion, but he probed the frontiers of avant-garde physics and psychology. He was an orthodox Calvinist even though he doubted his own salvation and feared the flames of Hell. He was an intellectual who, in the hierarchy of values, placed the impulses of the heart above the reasoned judgments of the mind. He was from birth a comfortable and prosperous man who, late in life, moved to the barren outer reaches of the frontier to work among the Indians.

Above all, Jonathan Edwards was an early 18th-century conservative who by his thought and by his personal courage has much to teach those of us who profess to be late 20th-century political lib­erals. For Edwards’s lifelong labors resulted not on­ly in brilliant books and essays but in the leading event of American colonial history, the First Great Awakening. The Awakening was marked by wide­spread and often frenzied religious conversions, which alone makes it something from which many modern liberals recoil. Such a response is utterly foolish. Written in the record of 18th-century re­vivalism is the nexus that, in American culture, has undergirded every important period of lasting re­form, the nexus between religious transformation, personal kindness, and social progress.

Enjoyed reading this?



You May Also Enjoy

The News You May Have Missed

Brother Laptop, Sister Cell Phone... Easing into the End Times... Maybe the Horses Can Help... Humanism in the Halls of Power... Worse Than a Root Canal,Better Than Gonorrhea... A Drinky for Doggy... With Friends Like These… Beam Us Up... Who's the Evil Empire Now?

Briefly: March 1989

Reviews of Doctrinal Standards in the Wesleyan Tradition... Correspondence of Flannery O'Connor and the Brainard Che­neys... Patrology, Volume IV: The Gold­en Age of Latin Patristic Litera­ture... Self-Fulfilling Prophecy: Exile and Return in the History of Ju­daism... The Ordeal of Civility: Freud, Marx, Levi-Strauss, and the Jew­ish Struggle with Modernity... Against the Protestant Gnostics... Marxism and Religion: A Descrip­tion and Assessment of the Marx­ist Critique of Christianity... Letters of Etienne Gilson to Hen­ri de Lubac... Letters of Marshall McLuhan... The Altruistic Personality: Res­cuers of Jews in Nazi Europe... First Steps in Prayer

A Belated Apology to Pope Paul VI

Recent petitions by German, Austrian, and French Catholics have demanded that the Church reconsider her…