Volume > Issue > Is Yoga Good, Bad, Neutral — or What?

Is Yoga Good, Bad, Neutral — or What?

Yoga Unveiled: My Spiritual Journey from Darkness to Light

By Linda Carl

Publisher: Sophia Institute Press

Pages: 173

Price: $17.95

Review Author: Pieter Vree

Pieter Vree is Editor the NOR and co-editor, with Thomas Storck, of Catholics and the American Polity: Approaches and Contestations (Arouca Press, 2025).

Did you know a “yoga war” is being waged right now? Neither did I, until I read Susan Brinkman’s foreword to Linda Carl’s Yoga Unveiled. Are you aware that yoga is “one of the most acrimonious subjects in the Church today”? No? Join the club.

Evidently, a fierce battle is raging right under our noses between “yogaphobes” and yoga “fanatics” (or, alternatively, “religious fanatics” and “yoga enthusiasts”), and it’s become so “heated,” Brinkman says, that “neither side can make a point because each one is too busy talking over the other.”

Talking? Oh. So, this isn’t a war per se but a hotly contested war of words. Indeed, Brinkman dials back the martial rhetoric, finally describing the conflict as a “yoga debate.” And in this debate, she says, the participants “should avoid the use of insulting labels,” as exposure to “well-reasoned arguments” from “both sides” can be a “powerful and rewarding learning experience.”

Okay, this definitely isn’t a war. In fact, Carl’s book is, Brinkman says, a “nonjudgmental treatment” of the topic.

Nonjudgmental! Does this even rise to the level of a debate? Not really. Evidently, it’s more of a conversation, which seems fitting once Brinkman signs off her foreword as Director of New Age Research for Women of Grace. That tracks, as the stated purpose of Women of Grace is to “empower” women,” encourage “friendship and sisterhood,” and promote “spiritual growth based on God’s Word.” There’s no call for crushing opponents when empowerment and sisterhood are the order of the day. Seems this can all be settled over a cozy cup of tea. And it explains the gentle hues of light blue and the soft-focus titles on the cover of the book, which wouldn’t be out of place on the self-help shelf of your local Barnes & Noble (provided there’s still a location near you).

And yet, it makes sense that this book would be marketed to women. Of the 36 million yoga practitioners in over 50,000 studios in the United States, some 75 percent are women, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Of all American women, 23 percent practice yoga, compared to ten percent of men. Yoga is a big business — it’s a hundred-billion-dollar industry — and Catholics, particularly Catholic women, are not immune to its charms.

Carl was one of many who were led astray. As she advanced in the practice of yoga and became an instructor, she still considered herself a faithful Catholic. She was a daily communicant and an extraordinary minister of Holy Communion, and she sent her kids to Catholic school. Yoga was, she thought, a healthy pursuit, great for exercise and stress relief, for imparting a sense of peace and well-being. She became a yoga evangelist of sorts, even hosting retreats and workshops at her parish, with the encouragement of the priests. Her love for yoga and her faith in Christ vied for her heart. Guess which won out? “My life became centered on yoga and its philosophies,” she writes. “I encouraged everyone to give it a try, certain it was life’s great panacea and that by teaching and promoting it I was helping people grow physically, mentally, and spiritually.”

As St. Clare of Assisi said, “We become what we love, and who we love shapes what we become.” Carl’s involvement in yoga opened her to other New Agey spiritual practices: Reiki, tarot cards, astrology, and “channelings.” Make no mistake — not the one Carl made, which led her to some very dark places — yoga isn’t merely a physical activity; it’s a spiritual discipline, a sacred Hindu ritual, though its “veiled spirituality,” Carl says, “is easy to miss.” It led her to an encounter with Satan.

Spirituality, Carl writes, “cannot be neutral; it must be tied to something.” Yoga is a Sanskrit word that means to yoke, bind, or join. It seeks to bind the practitioner’s mind, body, and soul to the supreme Hindu god, Brahman. Every yoga and yoga-adjacent mention of “the divine,” “god,” “energy,” and “universal consciousness” is a reference to Brahman.

But can’t Christians enjoy the physical benefits of yoga without getting into all the spiritual stuff? No. Yoga poses are Hindu prayer postures. Even the word namaste, which we presume to mean “thank-you,” translates to “The divine in me salutes the divine in you.” It’s a Hindu spiritual salutation. Carl cites Subhas Tiwari, professor of yoga and meditation at Hindu University of America in Orlando, Florida, who says, “Efforts to separate yoga from its spiritual center reveal ignorance of the goal of yoga,” which is to achieve enlightenment and thereby live in communion with Brahman. Christianity, on the other hand, preaches union of the mind, body, and soul with Jesus Christ. The two religions are, frankly, incompatible. Jesus is not synonymous with “energy,” nor is He “the universe.” Rather, He is the creator of both. Yoga cannot be baptized, made into an adjunct of Catholicism, nor can it be sanitized of its Hindu origins.

Attempting to blend religions is called syncretism, a spiritually dangerous practice, as Carl learned the hard way. “Bringing Jesus to a worship ritual with Hindu gods denies He is God,” she writes. By contrast, “Hindus do not attend Mass to grow closer to Brahman.” Remember what the Bible says about serving two masters? “If you think yoga is drawing you closer to God,” Carl warns, “you have been duped into growing closer to a false one.”

Or false ones. Accounts (and beliefs) vary, but some say there are 33 million gods in Hinduism, others 33,000 or 3,000. Whatever the number, “it bears an intriguing similarity to the number of fallen angels” in the Book of Revelation, Carl points out, one-third or 33 percent of the angels in Heaven. Demons, she claims, hide behind the Hindu deities who are summoned in yoga classes. “Every single yoga class, no matter where or how it is done,” she writes, “promotes communion with these evil spirits.” An example: In preparation for her Ashtanga teaching credential, Carl was required to memorize a Sanskrit invocation, unaware that it translates to “I bow and prostrate to the sage Patanjali” — an ancient Indian mystic whose name means fallen angel — and “the divine serpent who has assumed the form of man.” Such invocations and mantras are appeals to these and like entities to aid the practitioner along the path to enlightenment. One of Satan’s tricks, Carl writes, is to “make his dark world appear light-filled.” The name Lucifer means “bringer of light,” which isn’t far removed from enlightenment.

Kundalini, Carl writes, is “likely the most dangerous of all the forms of yoga.” Kundalini is a Sanskrit word meaning “coiled” or “snake,” and this form of yoga is meant to awaken this serpent (or snake energy) so it can travel up the spine and be released through the head. Catholic exorcists report that possessions resulting from the practice of Kundalini yoga are among the most difficult to break.

Carl recounts stories of a few women (including Moira Noonan, who’s written for the NOR) who struggled to free themselves from yoga’s grip, one of whom was dogged by suicidal ideation and turned to a deliverance team for help. During one session, she lost muscle control, and her body involuntarily contorted into yoga poses. Another woman says she was oppressed by a demon who revealed his name to be Yoga. As for Carl, she began seeing specters while performing Reiki on students after leading yoga classes. Twice she saw a “dark shadow” fly out of people’s bodies and hover above them. This, a member of an exorcism team later told her, was Satan himself.

To the untold number of Christian and Catholic women who have been seduced by yoga’s charms, and to the men who love them, Carl advises: “Never believe [Satan’s] lie that yoga is not religious in nature…that doing it without any religious intention makes it safe. All aspects of yoga and the New Age should be thoroughly purged to keep you safe.”

Susan Brinkman was right the first time: This is a war. Every Christian is in a spiritual battle, and yoga has convinced too many of Christ’s foot soldiers to give up the good fight, simply by virtue of their ignorance of what yoga really is. Even if you dismiss Brinkman’s, Carl’s, and so many other Christian women’s testimonies about the seemingly innocuous but spiritually risky aspects of yoga — if you side with the yoga enthusiasts — Carl has a word for you, too: “Demons don’t randomly possess people, they need an opening. Why give them one?” Whatever the alleged physical benefits of yoga, they’re not worth the risk to your soul.

 

©2026 New Oxford Review. All Rights Reserved.

 

To submit a Letter to the Editor, click here.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

A Case of Demonic Possession

Psychiatrists as a group are generally not very open to, or knowledgeable about, the distinct possibility of demonic possession.

Indiff’rent Strokes

In blurting out his opinion of the supposedly wonderful and God-gifted diversity of religions in a slapdash manner, Francis does great injustice to the Catholic religion.

Medium Unwell

We are caught in a new age of New Age, a time of technological idolatry in which everyone is fighting in a spiritual war that so very few even realize is underway.