Volume > Issue > If Everyone Is Saved...

If Everyone Is Saved…

WHY BOTHER?

By Dale Vree | January 2001
Dale Vree is Editor of the NOR.

In “The Public Square” section of First Things (June/July 2000), Fr. Richard John Neuhaus expressed dismay that the NEW OXFORD REVIEW would contest Catholic theologian Hans Urs von Balthasar on the issue of Hell. Fr. Neuhaus was referring to the article, “The Inflated Reputation of Hans Urs von Balthasar” by Fr. Regis Scanlon (NOR, March 2000).

Neuhaus said: “Balthasar was held in highest esteem by Cardinal Ratzinger, and, shortly before his death in 1988, the Pope announced that he would be made a cardinal. I don’t know what NOR is up to by attacking Balthasar. Whether one can be more orthodox than the Magisterium is doubtful. Why one would want to be is puzzling.” In other words, the NOR was presuming to be more orthodox than the Magisterium when it published Fr. Scanlon’s article.

On the matter of Balthasar, Fr. Neuhaus apparently has a more expansive understanding of the Magisterium than the Magisterium has of itself. Look! Just because Cardinal Ratzinger holds a theologian in highest esteem and the Pope announces that that theologian is to be made a cardinal does not mean that everything — or anything — that theologian wrote before being raised to the episcopate is part of the Magisterium.

Fr. Neuhaus also noted that he had just published a book pertaining to the question of Hell, Death on a Friday Afternoon (Basic Books). I, as Editor of the NOR, took that as a nudge, and read it.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! GET A FREE 7 DAY TRIAL

SUBSCRIBE TODAY

You May Also Enjoy

Is Hell Closed Up & Boarded Over?

Where eternal rewards and punishments are concerned, are we more tenderhearted and clear-eyed than our forebears in faith -- than God Himself?

Plan A & Plan B

George Kendall has problems with the belief held by many traditional Catholics that the majority of mankind is damned.

Choose Your Own Eternity

What follows death is the extension into eternity of what we chose in this world. When we pass from this life, what we wanted here will be what we want forever.