Volume > Issue > Icons, Relics & Pilgrimages: A Secular Defense

Icons, Relics & Pilgrimages: A Secular Defense

GUEST COLUMN

By Charles N. Bertolami | October 2024
Charles N. Bertolami teaches ethics in health care at the New York University College of Dentistry, where he is professor of oral and maxillofacial surgery and dean of the college.

The veneration of icons and relics finds its origin in human rationality and reason. Yet the secular world disparages this act of piety as irrational, misconstruing icons as idols, veneration as worship, and the miraculous as superstition. This despite everyday life bringing about states of mind indistinguishable from veneration but without evoking the attendant charge of irrationality.

Relics are objects rendered holy by their origin and history. Icons are usually pictorial representations rendered holy by their association with the miraculous. Japanese art historian Akira Akiyama observes that relics are dividable but not duplicable. Icons are duplicable but not dividable. In both cases, value derives not from material composition but from immaterial attributes. The immaterial is recognized as real. This is not some idle speculation but a felt reality — even by people living strictly secular lives.

By way of example, in the early 1990s, a Leeds property developer paid £100,000 for a painting entitled Nude, 1909-10 by Marc Chagall. The provenance was not impeccable, but the painting did appear in the 1989 book Chagall: The Russian Years 1907-1922 by Aleksandr Kamensky, a friend of Chagall. Two decades later, the developer became concerned when a subsequent reprinting of Kamensky’s book omitted the painting he had purchased. Based on provenance, connoisseurship, and forensic analysis, the painting was determined to be a fake. Taking inflation into consideration, the value of the painting dropped from the equivalent today of £237,070 ($301,900) to zero. Why? The painting itself had not changed.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

Will the Coronavirus Lockdowns Usher in a Mustard-Seed Church?

The willful suppression of the sacraments by Catholic leaders could portend the diminution of the Church in both numbers and influence.

God Be in My Hand -- or on My Tongue?

In Church law, the communicant has the right to receive on the tongue or in the hand, and the further right to receive standing or kneeling.

Spiritus Domini: How the Exception Became the Rule

The Pope's decision to allow women into two “minor orders” of the Church shows how significant change can be instituted incrementally.