Volume > Issue > Heaven: A Stumbling Block?

Heaven: A Stumbling Block?

WHAT DO WE REALLY BELIEVE ABOUT ETERNAL LIFE?

By Mike Filce | March 2025
Mike Filce lives in South Lake Tahoe, attends Our Lady of Tahoe Catholic Church, and teaches English at South Tahoe High School. He and his wife, Anne, are parents to a son and a daughter.

As unbelievable as it might sound, we Catholics have a couple problems with the idea of Heaven — and by “problems” I mean the kind that are so big they can make us indifferent to the idea of eternal life in Heaven and, consequently, poorly motivated to get there. We’re ashamed to admit it, but most of us probably have a rather low opinion of the thing we imagine as Heaven. How could it be otherwise? All we know of ineffable bliss is what we’ve seen here on Earth, and we have seen some amazing sights, indeed. But we have no capacity for imagining much beyond that — much less imagining how it wouldn’t become tiresome, given the eternal nature of it all.

As rough as earthly life can be, at least it’s dynamic, with its ups and downs, highs and lows. Heaven, on the other hand, is usually presented as a permanent state of joy, which is great, except we are suspicious of the seemingly static, for we have no way to comprehend that. And what we can’t fathom, we can’t fully appreciate. And then we’re promised a resurrected body, but we can’t imagine what that’d be for, either. Many of the physical pleasures we prize are hard to imagine taking place in Heaven. Sure, we also have plenty of G-rated bodily pleasures, but you get the idea.

So, what’s the big issue here? Well, it’s bigger than we acknowledge because that which we cannot imagine, we cannot fully orient ourselves toward. Consequently, we usually don’t. I think it boils down to two big problems in our thinking and motivation: the promise and purpose of Heaven, and the point of having a resurrected body.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

When the Gospel Seems Like Bad News

The Bible has become a hot property in recent years. There is no end of…

Homosexuality & the Maccabean Revolt

The Greek polytheists and their Hellenizing allies in Jerusalem tried to woo the Jewish upper classes away from Yahwism with homosexuality.

Why American Politics Marginalizes Catholic Voters

American Catholics must be careful not to be more American than Catholic, especially since American politics is essentially Protestant.