Volume > Issue > A Plea to the Clergy from the Pews

A Plea to the Clergy from the Pews


By Marian E. Crowe | June 1996
Marian E. Crowe is Adjunct Assistant Professor in the Freshman Writing Program at the University of Notre Dame.

Several months ago my pastor began his homily by asking members of the congregation to stand up and mention bad things they had heard in the news recently. People mentioned a hurricane, the shooting of a policeman, a young girl found murdered, and the war in Bosnia. The pastor then read again a portion of the passage from Habakkuk that had been part of that Sunday’s readings: “How long, O Lord? I cry out for help but you do not listen? I cry out to you, ‘Violence!’ but you do not intervene. Why do you let me see ruin: Why must I look at misery?” (Hab. 1:1-3). The pastor went on to ask, “What can God do except what He can do through us? We are the hands of God.” He asked us to search our own hearts in terms of the suffering going on right around us. What were we doing about the homeless in our community? What were we doing about the suffering people in our neighborhood?

I admire this priest’s wholehearted dedication to social justice and his efforts to get his parishioners to take personal responsibility for building it. And yet, the homily left me feeling disquieted and perplexed. Some reflection has helped me clarify what disturbed me about this homily — and so many others I hear.

For starters, I have problems with the theology that underlies it: that God can work only through us. I know that many modern theologians say that it is immature and naive to expect that our prayers of petition will cause God to bring about change. Fr. Richard McBrien, in his Catholicism, states:

In prayers of petition, we explicitly come to terms with our needs and those of other people. We make ourselves ever more sensitive to our obligations to do whatever is possible to fulfill those needs…. Prayer, in other words, does not effect a change in God but in ourselves.

Enjoyed reading this?



You May Also Enjoy

Cardinal Kasper's Merciful Incoherencies

During Pope Francis’s first Angelus address after ascending to the chair of Peter, he approvingly…

Humanity's Ancient & Passionate Love Affair With War

We all talk as though we hate war. But this is never much more than a half-truth. However reluctant we may be to admit it, men love war.

The Drama of the Oxford Movement

John Henry Newman, Rob­ert and Henry Wilberforce, and Henry Manning came to realize that their struggle was nothing less than the eternal question of "whom shall ye serve?"