Mary as Co-Redemptrix: Why Not
GUEST COLUMN
The other day I was speaking with my friend Richard, a Catholic convert and Church historian. He told me that often during the past millennia, when a heresy reared its head, its well-meaning opponents inadvertently created another heresy in their attempt to correct the first one. Case in point: Nestorianism vs. Monophysitism. The Nestorians held that Christ had divine and human natures but was two distinct persons who were only loosely united. To counter this, the Monophysites alleged that Christ had only one nature, a divine nature that effectively absorbed His human nature. It took the Council of Chalcedon (A.D. 451) to condemn both by declaring the dogma of the hypostatic union: Jesus Christ is one person with two distinct natures, divine and human, united “without confusion, change, division, or separation.”
This example shows that debate is permissible when a doctrine has not been authoritatively defined. In fact, debate can be the impetus for clarifying erroneous ideas. And debate is what I would like to engage in regarding the current tumult over the title of the Blessed Virgin Mary as “Co-Redemptrix.”
In 1996, as prefect of the then-Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger rejected requests to describe Mary as Co-Redemptrix, stating, “Negative. The precise meaning of [the title] is not clear…. It is not clear how the doctrine expressed in [this title] is present in Scripture and the apostolic tradition.” Then, in 2002, the future Pope Benedict XVI again rejected use of the title, saying, “The formula ‘Co-redemptrix’ departs to too great an extent from the language of Scripture and of the Fathers and therefore gives rise to misunderstandings…. Everything comes from [Christ]…; Mary, too, is everything that she is through Him. The word ‘Co-redemptrix’ would obscure this origin.”
But when the now-Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith declared Co-Redemptrix “inappropriate” in Mater Populi Fidelis (2025), all hell broke loose.
You May Also Enjoy
My only hope was to make Jesus more fully the center of my life, the heart of my heart, the lover of my soul, the bridegroom of my spirit.
As seen in Mary, women have unique authority as "the source of life in relation to [Christ] in the completion of the New Covenant."
The mental image most people have of Our Blessed Mother has probably been generated and…