The Narthex
New Oxford Blog
On Election 2025
Catholic leadership is politically inept, and the U.S. Church has largely lost its political punch
By John M. Grondelski | November 5th 2025 6:05 PMFor the children of this world are more shrewd in dealing with their own kind than are the children of the light. – Luke 16:8
A pro-abortion zealot was elected Governor of Virginia. In her victory speech, she pledged to protect abortion for the next four years, making… READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Church in Italy’s LGBT Synodal Turn
Poor deluded priests & prelates who believe they can fill churches by embracing dubious causes
By Sabino Paciolla | November 5th 2025 11:56 AMThe Third Synodal Assembly of the Italian Church marked a historic turning point in its pastoral approach to LGBT people. With approval of the Synodal Path's summary document, "Yeast of Peace and Hope," the Italian Episcopal Conference (CEI) overwhelmingly approved proposals that represent an unprecedented openness toward homosexual and transgender…
READ FULL BLOG POSTChange and Continuity
On Newman's 'Development of Christian Doctrine' & Church teaching on the death penalty
By James Hanink | November 4th 2025 12:22 PMPope Leo has made it official: St. John Henry Newman is a Doctor of the Church. In this I rejoice; Newman has long been a favorite of mine. I often taught his An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent (1870), a classic in the epistemology of religion, in…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRandom Ruminations #31
Mary as Rorschach Test... The Spirit by Appointment?... Swimming the Thames ... and more
By John M. Grondelski | November 3rd 2025 1:06 PMSNAP Shutdown The continuing shutdown of the federal government has interrupted SNAP payments. SNAP is a federal program to provide food money to the poor. There are currently more than 41 million SNAP recipients. This seems to be one of those areas where the priority of the poor comes into…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPriest Compares the TLM to Halloween
Irreverence toward tradition, liturgical ignorance, and grave misinformation, all at once
By Sabino Paciolla | October 31st 2025 11:19 AMIn recent days, during a Mass dedicated to children, a parish priest in Italy uttered remarks that left many faithful disconcerted:
Let me say first up: it's not a sin if you have a Halloween party on October 31st. It's not a sin, even if some idiots say…
READ FULL BLOG POSTImmigration and Labor Globalization
Ignoring workers' legal status is unjust and contrary to Catholic social teaching
By John M. Grondelski | October 30th 2025 11:38 AMIn a recent essay, I quoted approvingly Oren Cass’s observation that employment, labor, and immigration law form a coherent legal whole that protects both national security and domestic workers. Summarizing Cass, immigration law determines who can work; employment law fixes “baseline” criteria for the employer-employee relationship; and labor law protects…
READ FULL BLOG POSTItalian Bishops' Synodal Document Opens to LGBT
The errors of the German Church officially spread to Italian soil
By Sabino Paciolla | October 28th 2025 12:03 PMThe Third Synodal Assembly of the Church in Italy marked a historic turning point in the pastoral approach to LGBT people. With the approval of “Yeast of Peace and Hope,” its Synodal Path Summary Document, the Italian Episcopal Conference (CEI) overwhelmingly approved proposals representing unprecedented openness toward homosexual and transgender…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRead the Letter of St. Jude!
The Epistle is brief, one chapter of just 25 verses, but it is exceedingly rich and evergreen
By John M. Grondelski | October 28th 2025 10:49 AMToday is the feast of Ss. Simon and Jude. They are two of the lesser known apostles, although in the American Church in the 20th century, there was a popular devotion to St. Jude Thaddeus. Many parishes conducted novenas to him as patron of impossible causes and things despaired of.…
READ FULL BLOG POSTImmigration & Priority of Labor over Capital
By backing illegal immigration, churchmen bless a system that exploits workers & enriches capital
By John M. Grondelski | October 27th 2025 11:29 AMIn his video defending immigrants, Chicago archbishop Blase Cupich begins by talking about migrants without regard to their status. “We stand with the father who labors in silence to build a better future.” Then, speaking expressly to immigrants “without documents,” Cupich adds, “Most of you have been here for years.…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMigration History Matters
Most of the immigrants helped by Mother Cabrini and Bishop Scalabrini were likely here legally
By John M. Grondelski | October 22nd 2025 11:01 AM“Migration” features, albeit in limited fashion, in Pope Leo XIV’s Apostolic Exhortation, Dilexi Te. Of the three paragraphs that mention it, two are historical. I am not a professional historian but I think I know enough to ask some questions about what those two paragraphs really support versus what some…
READ FULL BLOG POST50 Years of Grace
Missionary of Charity Brothers work with 'the unwanted, the lonely, the old, the disabled'
By James Hanink | October 21st 2025 1:31 PMA few weeks ago, the Missionary of Charity Brothers celebrated the 50th Anniversary of their presence in Los Angeles. First, a bit of history. With the blessing of their foundress Mother Teresa, in 1966 Br. Andrew (originally a Jesuit priest) began his service as co-founder of the Congregation, centered in…
READ FULL BLOG POSTInverted Pneumatology?
Many Western European clerics seem to think the Spirit moves mostly outside the Church
By John M. Grondelski | October 21st 2025 12:21 PMPneumatology is that branch of theology dealing with the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit is understood as indwelling in the Church and keeping her from error. The Church’s inerrancy is neither political nor historical; she can and has made mistakes in those areas. The Church’s inerrancy is related to her…
READ FULL BLOG POSTEU Pushes New Five-Year Gender Plan
Why is Brussels moving in the opposite direction from the UK and USA?
By Sabino Paciolla | October 20th 2025 12:17 PMThe European Union adopted in October 2025 its “LGBTIQ+ Equality Strategy 2026-2030,” a document that immediately sparked heated debate across the continent. The strategy, officially presented by the European Commission, promises to raise the bar on rights, safety, and inclusion for LGBTIQ+ people, but some of its content is generating…
READ FULL BLOG POSTIt Takes IVF to Make a Village
A Polish MP touts the government’s “success” in funding the making of 6,000 babies via IVF
By John M. Grondelski | October 15th 2025 6:45 PMIs producing 6,000 babies in test tubes an “achievement” for a government? Yes, apparently, according to Polish parliamentarian Weronika Smarduch. October 15 marks the second anniversary of the election of Donald Tusk’s current left-leaning government which she supports. Its apologists have taken to social media to tout its “achievements.” MP…
READ FULL BLOG POSTChat Control: One EU Battle Won
But the war for privacy, and thus for democracy, continues
By Sabino Paciolla | October 14th 2025 11:00 AMWriting in the October 9 Die Welt, Andreas Rosenvelder observed that then-Google CEO Eric Schmidt said something remarkable in a 2009 interview: "If there's something you don't want anyone to know, maybe you shouldn't do it.” The advice seems harmless, like that of an older brother, but it's also the…
READ FULL BLOG POST