The Narthex
Status of SSPX Faithful?
Canonical chaos stands in need of papal intervention
By Sabino Paciolla | November 12th 2026 12:36 PMFour months after the episcopal consecrations celebrated by the Priestly Society of Saint Pius X absent pontifical mandate, the canonical effects of the decree and the explanatory note published on July 2 by the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith (DDF) remain controversial. A reconstruction by Infovaticana on November…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMore Critiques of Cardinal Vesco
The freedom to convert constitutes, for the Church, a spiritual need and a fundamental right
By Sabino Paciolla | November 3rd 2026 11:14 AMThe words of Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco, Archbishop of Algiers, have sparked reactions and questions about the Church's mission. I have reiterated Vesco's statements in an interview with CathoBel, dedicated to the Catholic presence in a predominantly Muslim society. The cardinal described the Algerian Church as part of the people among…
READ FULL BLOG POSTDialogue Obscuring Proclamation
The Case of Cardinal Vesco
By Sabino Paciolla | October 30th 2026 12:36 AMAn article by Niwa Limbu in AdVaticanum reports the words spoken on October 23 by Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco, Archbishop of Algiers, in an interview with CathoBel. The conversation concerned evangelization in a predominantly Muslim society. For Vesco, the Algerian Church is part of the people among whom it lives: "We…
READ FULL BLOG POSTItalian Prelates Trade Truth for 'Realpolitik'
On the difference between defending oneself from an unjust law and promoting an unjust law
By Sabino Paciolla | September 16th 2026 10:38 AMFaced with the escalating public debate on end-of-life care, the Catholic Church in Italy is undergoing one of the most dramatic theological and political reversals in its recent history. This is no longer a silent retreat or passive tolerance in the face of secularization, but a veritable genetic mutation. Led…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWojtyła & Vatican II
John Paul II's teaching and focus on proper implementation of the Council seems to have been lost
By John M. Grondelski | May 18th 2026 12:13 PMToday is Karol Wojtyła’s/St. John Paul II’s 126th birthday. He was born on Tuesday, May 18, 1920. It is hard to believe that, after a 26-year pontificate supplemented by eight of the Ratzinger pontificate, the teaching and focus of the Wojtyła papacy as a lens to view the proper implementation…
READ FULL BLOG POSTStumbling Stone
The Church offers salvation, but to be saved implies needing to be saved from something
By John M. Grondelski | May 4th 2026 11:24 AMIn last week’s Gospel, Jesus called Himself the “sheepgate,” the sole legitimate entrance to the sheepfold. In this week’s Gospel, St. Peter calls Jesus the “cornerstone.” He also calls Him a “stone that will make people stumble and a rock that will make them fall” (1 Pt 2:8, quoting Is…
READ FULL BLOG POSTJonah, Signs, and the Modern 'Culture War'
Unlike the Israel of Jesus’ day, some modern churchmen aren’t even seeking a sign
By John M. Grondelski | February 26th 2026 1:01 AMAt Mass for Wednesday in the First Week of Lent, the First Reading focuses on Jonah’s successful conversion of the Ninevites. Threatening them with God’s destruction should they not mend their ways, “the people of Ninevah believed God; they proclaimed a fast and all of them, great and small, put…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPromising Signs on Italian Suicide Law
Events in Slovenia and France, plus words of Pope Leo & PM Meloni, help bishops find their spines?
By Sabino Paciolla | January 29th 2026 2:39 PMProfessor Benedetto Rocchi, Associate Professor in the Department of Economics and Business Science at the University of Florence and president of the permanent observatory on abortion, expressed his astonishment about the fight against assisted suicide in Italy in an article published in La Verità on September 7, 2025. He asked,…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Erosion of Epiphany
Epiphany used to have its own octave, meaning the Christmas Season extended until January 13
By John M. Grondelski | January 6th 2026 12:39 PMJanuary 6 is the traditional date for the Solemnity of the Epiphany. In the United States, it has been transferred for decades to the first Sunday after January 1. It fell on January 4 this year. Some liturgists would argue that Epiphany was, indeed, the original “Christmas” feast and that…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Erosion of January 1
U.S. Catholics do not understand why this is a holy day on the octave day of Christmas
By John M. Grondelski | January 5th 2026 1:07 PMThe Solemnity of Mary, Mother of God, celebrated on January 1, the Octave of Christmas, is a holyday of obligation. There’s an argument to be made that its status is progressively being eroded. Looking at some parish bulletins, I noticed a cutback in the number of Masses offered. That anecdotal…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRandom Ruminations #33
More Thoughts on “Christian Ownership Maximalism”... When Will They Ever Learn?... more
By John M. Grondelski | December 12th 2025 1:39 PMAnother Example of Inverted Pneumatology I’ve criticized a distorted theology of the Holy Spirit I’ve called “inverted pneumatology,” which pretends that today the Holy Spirit primarily speaks not to the world from the Church but rather teaches the Church from a secularized world. Writing in the National Catholic Reporter (I…
READ FULL BLOG POSTLet’s Support 'Christian Ownership Maximalism'
We need Catholic ecosystems. And, like it or not, they cost money
By John M. Grondelski | December 11th 2025 11:57 AMTimothy Reichert’s “Christian Ownership Maximalism” is an original article (linked below) in the December 2025 issue of First Things. It deserves wide readership, thorough debate, and I’d argue adoption in Catholic circles. Christendom as we have known it -- whether the religiously suffused culture of medieval Europe or the ethnic…
READ FULL BLOG POST'People, Look East': Risky?
Will some bishops restrict this hymn as a backdoor endorsement of versus orientem posture?
By John M. Grondelski | December 4th 2025 12:23 PMAdvent comes with a repertoire of hymnody unique to the season, such as “O Come, O Come, Emmanuel.” Among traditional Advent hymns now sung in English-speaking Catholic churches is Englishwoman Eleanor Farjeon’s “People, Look East,” which was sung in my parish last Sunday. I had to wonder whether some dioceses…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Culture of Life Prevails in Slovenia
When the Church is united, it can still win seemingly lost battles
By Sabino Paciolla | December 1st 2025 11:39 AMOn November 23, Slovenia said no to euthanasia. With 53% of voters voting against and 46% in favor, Slovenians rejected a law that would have allowed terminally ill patients to receive assistance in ending their lives. This was not a narrow margin due to abstentions: Turnout reached nearly 41%, with…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhat the Maccabees Could Teach Modern Catholics
As Western European clerics are again singing the praises of secularization
By John M. Grondelski | November 19th 2025 7:20 PMSome Western European clerics are again singing the praises of secularization. The latest, according to Stefano Fontana, is Cardinal Matteo Zuppi, the president of the Conference of Catholic Bishops of Italy. (His November 17 opening address to the bishops’ meeting in Assisi is linked below.) That song, however, is hardly…
READ FULL BLOG POST