‘World Vasectomy Day’

The annual sterilization push offers a chance for discussion of life-affirming Catholic sexual ethics

Did you know? November 20 is “World Vasectomy Day.” It is an annual observance, on the third Friday of November, to urge men to submit to sterilization. It is a global event. As this year’s agenda indicates, we can follow the path of the sun around the world, listening to doctors — especially in the Third World — expatiate on the value of cutting your vasa deferentia (the off-putting website, heavy with exclamation points, is here).

From a purely utilitarian viewpoint, male sterilization is more effective than female contraception. Women are only periodically fertile, i.e., for a few days per month during a limited number of years. Men are almost always fertile from puberty until they die. And vasectomy is economically advantageous: unlike contraceptives, which must be constantly obtained and consumed, a few snips and… causa finita.

And yet, male sterilization never took off.

Yes, compared to “the Pill,” it is more invasive — albeit on a one-time basis. Take Friday afternoon off, get “it” done, retire to your man-cave for the weekend, and binge on football. Still…

In the post-Dobbs world in 2022, World Vasectomy Day proponents tried to package sterilization as a sign of solidarity with women. Now that their “right” to kill their unborn child had been modified by the Supreme Court, guys should “man up” and take charge of their fertility by destroying it for the woman they “love.”

And yet, it hasn’t taken off. Why?

In traditional Catholic moral theology, sterilization (like sex reassignment surgery) was treated under the rubric “mutilation.” Yes, sterilization had a contraceptive effect, but contraception was effectuated by a radical damage of the body, an invasive procedure that cut things up.

Let me suggest the insight of Catholic moral theology finds resonance in men’s responses: There is a visceral awareness that something is being mutilated, something is being destroyed. And there also seems to be a visceral awareness that what is being destroyed is not, by its nature, something bad. A guy can understand and not question cutting out his appendix or gall bladder due to pathologies, but somehow he instinctually recognizes his capacity to become a father is part of him and not something bad. Maybe it’s a refined calculus; in an age of increasing divorce, why forego a capacity the next woman might value? But I think the matter is less cynical. Somewhere, deep down, a man simply does not think his fertility is bad.

He may project that “badness” (namely, “inconvenience”) onto others. This is why so-called responsible parenthood has typically fallen on women and why abortion-on-demand as contraceptive backup remains supposedly “necessary” for “women’s equality.” But male projection about men’s irresponsibility does not turn male sexuality (as opposed to some men’s behavior) into something bad. And, when confronted with the practical finality of vasectomy, most men grasp that, even if perhaps only unconsciously.

Let me suggest, for Catholic theological purposes, that we meet folks where they are. If men nevertheless seem ambivalent about the quasi-permanent destruction of their fertility that vasectomy represents, is that not the starting point for a discussion about fertility as an essential aspect of human personhood (and not just a sometimes-inconvenient biological phenomenon)? As a way beyond the modern, dualistic Cartesian mindset that reduces the person to a thought and his body to a tool to be manipulated? As a way to move forward into a sexual ethic of communion that recognizes the woman’s fertility is also who she is and, therefore, the fundamental injustice of sexual double standards that traditionally allowed men to slough off responsibility for the consequences of their fertility?

World Vasectomy Day should not only be an annual opportunity for its proponents to push their agenda and, in some neighborhoods, host roving out-patient “services” (not unlike the “abortion providers” who set up camp around the 2024 Democratic convention). It should also be a chance to gain entrée to the discussion of Catholic sexual ethics from a somewhat uniquely male perspective — an entrée that can be far more life-changing and life-affirming.

 

John M. Grondelski (Ph.D., Fordham) was former associate dean of the School of Theology, Seton Hall University, South Orange, New Jersey. All views expressed herein are exclusively his.

From The Narthex

Random Ruminations #18

Romanian Rain on Francis’s Common Easter Parade Pope Francis’s idea of launching a “common Easter”…

More Questions for the L.A. Times

You might recall, gentle reader, that I’m putting together an Open Letter to the Editorial…

On Defining Religion Too Narrowly

On June 16, the U.S. Supreme Court kicked back Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany v.…