The Narthex
New Oxford Blog
Locating God: a Logical Point
God isn’t a species within some genus
By James Hanink | November 15th 2018 4:32 PMRemember the drill? Which of these things does not belong? Example #1 (apple, banana, carrot). Easy! A carrot isn’t a fruit, so it doesn’t belong. Example # 2 (cat, dog, butterfly). Well, a butterfly isn’t a mammal, so it doesn’t belong. The logical point in each example is that the…
READ FULL BLOG POST“Right-Left Mythology”
Labels are bound to create division, even in the Church
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | November 14th 2018 4:56 PMSelf-government in the political sense is only successful when each member of society is able to govern himself. That is, democracy only works when the people are virtuous. This truth, which has long been forgotten, was ever on the minds of the Founders and was the reason behind John Adams’s…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPapal Pollution
The Pope has power over only one global problem
By Richard DellOrfano | November 12th 2018 3:51 PMPope Francis is humanely concerned with over a dozen man-made problems that even school kids would wonder why the world doesn’t do something about: plastics littering the oceans, deadly drug gangs in Mexico, insane wars sparked by the pride of men, murderous Christian persecutions in Muslim nations, materialistic culture and…
READ FULL BLOG POSTInfelicities
A quick pitch for verbal clarity
By James Hanink | November 9th 2018 4:16 PMHave you ever heard the protestation “There’s no such thing as a bad boy!” It’s what a doting grandmother might say, at least in Grand Rapids, Michigan. What did my grandmother really mean? Probably something like “There’s hope for him yet.” That was true, although it’s false that there’s no…
READ FULL BLOG POSTA Thanksgiving
Christ speaks to us through others
By Richard DellOrfano | November 8th 2018 4:33 PMIn a low-rent Beacon Hill tenement where I once lived, I visited almost daily a disabled pensioner who was a former horse jockey, recently suffering from blackouts. He had had a metal plate embedded in his skull after a racing tumble, and it caused him unpredictable fainting spells. His merely…
READ FULL BLOG POST‘Hate Speech’ at Another Catholic College
Will this Jesuit college alter its actions and its character?
By Barbara Rose | November 7th 2018 7:23 PMYou may recall New Oxford Review’s story of a Providence College student named Michael Smalanskas, who bravely confronted politically-correct college administrators over his display about traditional Church teaching on marriage (see “The New Hate Speech: Catholic Teaching at a Catholic College,” May 2018; link here: https://www.newoxfordreview.org/documents/the-new-hate-speech-catholic-teaching-at-a-catholic-college/). Now it’s another…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhat to Say When I Die
The spirit of the traditional Día de Los Muertos
By James Hanink | November 7th 2018 4:36 PMWhen I die, I’ll have plenty to say. But, gentle reader, you’ll not hear it. Friends, neighbors, and writers of obituaries will, no doubt, have something to say. Fortunately, with my not being an old soldier, no one will comment that “he just faded away.” Most of us, it seems,…
READ FULL BLOG POSTOvercoming the Masters of Suspicion
Freedom from slavery to our desires opens the path to authentic love
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | November 7th 2018 4:24 PMFriedrich Nietzsche once posited that the best way to defeat Christianity was to attack it not based on its truth but on its practical impossibility. From its impracticality the world will draw its own conclusions regarding its veracity. There is a certain diabolic deftness to an attack on this front…
READ FULL BLOG POSTJudgment Puzzles
Only God knows how any of us responds to His love
By James Hanink | November 1st 2018 3:39 PMPuzzles, especially real life puzzles, can drive us crazy. (When my dad was charged with doing this very thing, he’d reply “Sir/Madam, in your case it will be a short, quick trip.”) But puzzles can also lead to insight, and the harder the puzzle the more valuable the insight can…
READ FULL BLOG POSTBuying Happiness
The Church insists that human beings don’t reproduce but procreate
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | October 31st 2018 3:39 PMA lesbian couple in Texas has become the first such couple to give birth to a baby that they both carried. Using a technique dubbed Reciprocal Effortless IVF, one of the women had several of her eggs fertilized while she acted as an incubator using a device called INVOCell. After…
READ FULL BLOG POSTA Pitch for Practical Reason
Ensuring that good is done and evil is avoided
By James Hanink | October 26th 2018 3:13 PMLet’s list a few words: smart, clever, bright, ingenious. They’re all familiar. No one needs to make a pitch for aspiring to being smart, clever, bright, or ingenious. With “practical reason” we’re in a different territory. The term isn’t so familiar. It’s easy to confuse with “practicality.” And we can’t…
READ FULL BLOG POSTImmigration and the Common Good
Thomas Aquinas gives an example of a just immigration policy
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | October 25th 2018 3:12 PMAs reported in a number of news sources, there are now two separate “migrant caravans” heading towards the US-Mexico border, totaling about 10,000 migrants from Central American countries. Their crawl to the border is like a slow fuse sure to reignite the contentious debate over immigration. Protecting migrants is part…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMargaret Sanger Versus Gandhi
He foresaw frightful results from widespread use of birth control
By Richard DellOrfano | October 23rd 2018 4:56 PMMargaret Sanger, founder of Planned Parenthood, met with Mahatma Gandhi to gain his support for her promotion of birth control devices versus using self-control of sexual desire. She was sorely disappointed, as he predicted rampant licentiousness would result from widespread use of such devices. In 1934, an Indian…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPity the Poor Pragmatist
Pragmatism eliminates both real freedom and real bravery
By James Hanink | October 19th 2018 8:52 PMAmerica, it’s said, is the land of the free and home of the brave. It’s also said, and might well be true, that America flies the flag of pragmatism. But if we are pragmatists, then the star spangled banner is at risk. So is our freedom, and our bravery is…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPostcards for Africa
Attacking a sound-bite straw man only masks the real evil
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | October 19th 2018 6:35 PMIn a presentation at the Gates Foundation's “Goalkeepers” last month, French President Emmanuel Macron made comments that appeared to be critical of large families: “One of the critical issues of African demography is that this is not chosen fertility... I always say: ‘Present me the woman who decided, being perfectly…
READ FULL BLOG POST