No Quick Fix

True charity involves person-to-person interaction

I handed out clothing and served food at a Boston Catholic Worker House during the 1960s. Homeless veterans in army jackets lined up for hot meals and warm clothing during the winter. Day after day, the same dour faces came, ate, and left. They slept in vacant buildings at night and woke to repeat the same dull routine. Priests would preach to beggars who for a free meal pretended to listen.

Back then it was a charade, but things are different today. It took over 50 years, but now the Catholic Worker in Boston arranges for the homeless to live and work together. Newcomers learn how to bake wholesome breads that support their upkeep. Teaching a homeless man to bake his own loaf, rather than tossing him a slice, makes a big difference. This is not the fake charity of welfare’s free-handouts-forever that rob men of motivation. True charity doesn’t have that stale odor; rather, it confers skills that people enjoy doing so they can prosper.

Over the last week, Fox News investigative reporter Barnini Chakraborty has chronicled the growth of homelessness in four West Coast cities: Seattle, Portland, San Francisco, and Los Angeles. Chakraborty writes, “Residents, the homeless, and advocates say they’ve lost faith in their elected officials’ ability to solve the issue. Most of the cities have thrown hundreds of millions of dollars at the problem only to watch it get worse.” Chakraborty describes a scene in Los Angeles: “It’s the stale stench of liquor and human waste that hits you first. Then it’s visual — row after row of dirty tarp tents crammed together on the sidewalk next to piles of rotting trash and broken appliances.” She describes “half-dressed, drugged-out shells of people wandering aimlessly in the middle of the street,” as well as “fights, prostitution, and rodent burrows.” This, she says, is “the fabled Skid Row in Los Angeles and it’s a disaster.”

Residents of these cities find their compassion is “constantly being challenged by a fear for their own safety and quality of life” due to harassment by the mentally ill. Law-abiding citizens are demanding a remedy for the horrors of vagrancy spiraling out of control. They are tired of lame laws that do nothing to address the root of the problem.

Social injustice is complex but our problems stand to grow much worse. Perhaps the job-skills model of the Boston Catholic Worker deserves more widespread trial. Recall, from above, how “cities have thrown hundreds of millions of dollars at the problem only to watch it get worse.”

A similar model would well serve immigrants and refugees. Qualified volunteer teachers, nurses, pastors, farmers, electricians, barbers, and cooks could give them counsel and training. These volunteers could also ensure adequate living conditions wherever their trainees are kept by authorities. Of course, qualified nonprofit organizations would provide needed clothing, medicine, food, and other equipment.

They come ― the poor, the huddled masses yearning to breathe free. However, to release them into our streets — penniless, homeless, without proper sanitation, nutrition, clothing, and medical attention ― is actually a disguised cruelty.


Richard M. DellOrfano spent ten years on a cross-country pilgrimage following Christ’s instruction to minister without possessions. He is completing his autobiography: Path Perilous, My Search for God and the Miraculous.

From The Narthex

North American Martyrs

Today is the memorial of St. Isaac Jogues and Companions -- the 17th century Jesuit…

The Point of Politics

Good politics calls for building bridges and forming coalitions. The American Solidarity Party gets it.…

Marxism, Alive and Well

Conservative defenders of traditional Christian values often claim that many of the things they perceive…