The Narthex
'On Jordan’s Bank': Another Problem Hymn?
Advent classic is misaligned with contemporary political & pastoral sensibilities
By John M. Grondelski | December 9th 2025 12:22 PMFresh off last week’s discovery that "People, Look East" might be coded propaganda for a clandestine versus orientem revival, I approached this Sunday’s liturgy with heightened vigilance. Imagine my dismay when the next hymn announced itself: the venerable "On Jordan’s Bank" -- that paragon of Advent piety which, upon scrutiny,…
READ FULL BLOG POSTNew Ecclesiastical Fronts in the War on Christmas
Jesus, Mary, and Joseph are not props for a political message, even one bishops endorse
By John M. Grondelski | December 8th 2025 12:21 PMRecent years have seen a “war on Christmas.” It takes the form of turning Christmas into a holiday in the closet, daring not to speak its name. Instead, we say “happy holidays,” while kids get “winter break” from school. Those who contend there’s a war on Christmas argue that its…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhat the Maccabees Could Teach Modern Catholics
As Western European clerics are again singing the praises of secularization
By John M. Grondelski | November 19th 2025 7:20 PMSome Western European clerics are again singing the praises of secularization. The latest, according to Stefano Fontana, is Cardinal Matteo Zuppi, the president of the Conference of Catholic Bishops of Italy. (His November 17 opening address to the bishops’ meeting in Assisi is linked below.) That song, however, is hardly…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMy Veteran’s Day Campaign
A plenary indulgence specifically dedicated to the repose of the souls of fallen military personnel
By John M. Grondelski | November 10th 2025 1:59 PMCatholics have traditionally dedicated November to prayer for the souls in Purgatory, especially on All Souls' Day. To encourage efficacious prayer for the departed, the Church grants a plenary indulgence, under the usual conditions, to Catholics who visit a cemetery from November 1-8 and pray for the dead. The indulgence…
READ FULL BLOG POSTNovus Ordo, Versus Orientem, & Vatican II
Eighteen points on why these are all compatible
By John M. Grondelski | November 7th 2025 10:49 PMReports, officially unconfirmed, are circulating that some dioceses in the United States have prohibited celebration of the Novus Ordo Missae (NO) with a versus orientem posture. I offer some theological reflections: Since introduction of the NO in 1969, the usual posture for celebration of Mass has been versus populum, “towards…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Church in Italy’s LGBT Synodal Turn
Poor deluded priests & prelates who believe they can fill churches by embracing dubious causes
By Sabino Paciolla | November 5th 2025 11:56 AMThe Third Synodal Assembly of the Italian Church marked a historic turning point in its pastoral approach to LGBT people. With approval of the Synodal Path's summary document, "Yeast of Peace and Hope," the Italian Episcopal Conference (CEI) overwhelmingly approved proposals that represent an unprecedented openness toward homosexual and transgender…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRandom Ruminations #31
Mary as Rorschach Test... The Spirit by Appointment?... Swimming the Thames ... and more
By John M. Grondelski | November 3rd 2025 1:06 PMSNAP Shutdown The continuing shutdown of the federal government has interrupted SNAP payments. SNAP is a federal program to provide food money to the poor. There are currently more than 41 million SNAP recipients. This seems to be one of those areas where the priority of the poor comes into…
READ FULL BLOG POSTItalian Bishops' Synodal Document Opens to LGBT
The errors of the German Church officially spread to Italian soil
By Sabino Paciolla | October 28th 2025 12:03 PMThe Third Synodal Assembly of the Church in Italy marked a historic turning point in the pastoral approach to LGBT people. With the approval of “Yeast of Peace and Hope,” its Synodal Path Summary Document, the Italian Episcopal Conference (CEI) overwhelmingly approved proposals representing unprecedented openness toward homosexual and transgender…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRead the Letter of St. Jude!
The Epistle is brief, one chapter of just 25 verses, but it is exceedingly rich and evergreen
By John M. Grondelski | October 28th 2025 10:49 AMToday is the feast of Ss. Simon and Jude. They are two of the lesser known apostles, although in the American Church in the 20th century, there was a popular devotion to St. Jude Thaddeus. Many parishes conducted novenas to him as patron of impossible causes and things despaired of.…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMigration History Matters
Most of the immigrants helped by Mother Cabrini and Bishop Scalabrini were likely here legally
By John M. Grondelski | October 22nd 2025 11:01 AM“Migration” features, albeit in limited fashion, in Pope Leo XIV’s Apostolic Exhortation, Dilexi Te. Of the three paragraphs that mention it, two are historical. I am not a professional historian but I think I know enough to ask some questions about what those two paragraphs really support versus what some…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Need to Stop Grasping
Christ shows man the path by not 'grasping' himself but taking the form of obedient servant
By John M. Grondelski | September 16th 2025 11:56 AMLast Sunday’s Second Reading -- for the Exaltation of the Cross, which preempted the 24th Sunday of Ordinary Time -- was St. Paul’s great hymn of Jesus’ self-emptying, his kenosis (Phil 2:6-11). One of the key texts in that hymn is verse 6, where Jesus is presented as treating divinity…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhat Is 'True Freedom'?
Many hold to a false notion of freedom, one that treats freedom as an end rather than a means
By John M. Grondelski | September 9th 2025 11:39 AMThe Sunday homily usually reflects on the readings for that day. Typically, that means the Gospel and maybe the First Reading, which often is linked to the Gospel. The Second Reading is usually odd man out since in their wisdom the designers of the new Lectionary decided on a continual…
READ FULL BLOG POSTReligion: A Matter of Faith or Feelings?
Insipid hymns reveal a trade-in of a Catholicism built on faith and reason for one of emotions
By John M. Grondelski | August 20th 2025 12:33 PMAnthony Esolen has spilled no small amount of ink challenging the doctrinal and other issues that plague contemporary Catholic hymnody. Demonstrating how today’s “Catholic” ditties upend the traditional liturgical principle lex orandi, lex credendi (how we pray expresses what we believe) has almost become a cottage industry online. Recently, Trent…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Pilgrimages Have Begun
Faithful from all corners of Poland will converge on Czestochowa, Mary's national shrine, on Aug. 15
By John M. Grondelski | August 8th 2025 11:39 AMThe pilgrimages across Poland have begun. Every year in early August, from every corner of Poland, people set out on walking pilgrimages across the country to converge on Czestochowa, Mary's national shrine, on August 15. It's a multi-generational tradition. Parishes and local communities assemble and walk, usually 12-15 miles per…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRandom Ruminations #27
Parishes & Commandments of the Church... Adapting Just War Principles... Name-calling... more
By John M. Grondelski | July 17th 2025 5:55 PMParishes & Commandments of the Church Archbishop Edward Weisenberger of Detroit has supposedly told priests to remind Catholics attending Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) at one of the four non-parish venues in the Archdiocese where the TLM will at least occasionally be available that those attendees are nevertheless members of some…
READ FULL BLOG POST