The Narthex
Is Thomas's Doubt Bad?
We sometimes jump to conclusions about others’ motivations
By John M. Grondelski | April 30th 2025 11:17 AMThe Gospel of the Second Sunday of Easter (Jn 20:19-31) incorporates two appearances by Jesus to His Apostles. His first, on Easter Sunday evening, is the institution of the sacrament of Penance, entrusting the ministry of forgiveness to His Apostles. The second, a week later, is when he confronts “doubting…
READ FULL BLOG POSTCivil Problems with a 'Common Easter'
The ecumenical proposal could result in further erasure of Easter from U.S. civil life
By John M. Grondelski | April 24th 2025 11:48 AMWe recently considered the less-than-pretty side of the “ecumenical” push to impose a common Easter. (See my post from two days ago.) That essay notes that most discussion focuses on three possible approaches: have the East adopt the Catholic approach; have the West adopt the Orthodox approach; or have both…
READ FULL BLOG POSTEcumenical Problems with a 'Common Easter'
The impractical proposal in many ways could backfire and is not worth it
By John M. Grondelski | April 22nd 2025 11:37 AMMuch attention has been given this year to a push by the late Pope Francis (with Orthodox Patriarch Bartholomew) to find a date for a “common Easter.” Francis had resurrected a dormant appendix of Vatican II’s Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy as his warrant for the push which, one senses,…
READ FULL BLOG POSTIndivisible PDR
Just as we can’t have Easter without Good Friday, neither can we have Good Friday without Easter
By John M. Grondelski | April 21st 2025 11:52 AMBack in my undergraduate theology days Fr. Robert Werenski, our Bible professor, regularly came back to what he called the “PDR” -- the Passion, Death, and Resurrection of Jesus Christ. We Catholics call it the “Paschal Mystery,” which we just finished celebrating during the Paschal Triduum but still have seven…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhy Not 'Harden Your Heart'?
To receive sanctifying grace we must not resist God, play deaf, or put Him off
By John M. Grondelski | April 9th 2025 5:27 PMScripture exhorts us, “O, that today you would hear His voice, do not harden your hearts!” (Ps 95:7-8; Heb 3:7-8). Occasionally, that verse appears as a refrain to the Responsorial Psalm at Mass. For those who pray the Liturgy of the Hours, Morning Prayer usually begins with Psalm 95. Why…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Age of Bishops
If the Pope doesn't or shouldn't resign at 75, should diocesan bishops?
By John M. Grondelski | April 8th 2025 9:49 PMSocial media upended the news world by providing ordinary people an opportunity to raise and discuss matters the establishment media didn’t or wouldn’t. I’ve also found it a place to discover ideas that deserve further discussion but which, because they aren’t on the immediate news cycle, won’t get their due.…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRandom Ruminations #23
What’s in a Name?... “Forced Joy”... The “Business” of Government... and more
By John M. Grondelski | April 1st 2025 12:32 PMApril 1 … is more than “April Fool’s Day.” It’s the end of the first quarter of the year. Ninety days of 2025 down. Last year I made a point of marking each quarter of the year to invite readers to consider what they’d done (or not done) with New…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhere Is the Church? Who Is God?
A brief consideration of a pair of questions that involve 'subsistence'
By James Hanink | March 31st 2025 11:39 AM“What a difference a day makes,” sang Dinah Washington. And why? Because “24 little hours / Brought the sun and the flowers / Where there used to be rain.” But sometimes, we know, it just keeps raining. So, it depends on the day, doesn’t it? What about a word? What…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRandom Ruminations #22
Get Ready... Confused Catholicity... Permanent Foreigners... Liturgy Research... more
By John M. Grondelski | March 25th 2025 12:15 PMGet Ready Today is the Solemnity of the Annunciation. From today until Christmas is exactly nine months (for those of you who like to get "holiday" preparations underway early!). Today Jesus' Life began. Over the next several months, I'd like to remind readers on the 25th of just how Our…
READ FULL BLOG POSTLitany for Lawyers and Government Officials
Ecclesiastically approved for private devotion
By James Thunder | March 21st 2025 11:42 AMBelow is the Catholic Church’s first litany for lawyers and government officials. It has been ecclesiastically approved for private devotion. (Seven approved litanies exist for public devotion and dozens for private devotion.) I composed it for those who work, as I did, in the field of law as lawyers, legislators,…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRandom Ruminations #21
Let’s Get the Calendar... Unaccompanied Minors... Heaping Helping of Synodality... and more
By John M. Grondelski | March 20th 2025 11:33 AMLet’s Get the Calendar Minnesota Democratic Senator Amy Klobuchar was on social media March 19, proclaiming it as “Medicaid Day of Action.” I expected that shortly thereafter, 46 other blue Senators would repeat the same talking points. Can I ask some mole to please get us the calendar of Democratic…
READ FULL BLOG POSTGrief Will Become Joy
Crying after death, and the balm given to us by our love, the Holy Spirit -- Part 6
By James Thunder | March 17th 2025 12:26 PMThe Holy Spirit will be our Comforter, our Healer, hovering over a cauldron of people in purgatory who are seething with anger, bubbling with resentment. In their heart of hearts, they love God, but they can’t help their feelings. Their anger and their love rise and fall like a heart’s…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWords, Roots, & Meaning
In the anamnesis we actively enter into the ongoing drama of our redemption
By James Hanink | March 17th 2025 11:57 AM“If memory serves,” I sometimes say, which puts my wife on alert. Is my selective amnesia (from the Greek ἀ- "without" and μνήσις "memory") about to kick in? Maybe, but even so I’m the family archivist. Blimey! Who gets assigned to foraging in our archives, fittingly located in the shed…
READ FULL BLOG POSTHealing in Purgatory
Crying after death, and the balm given us by our love, the Holy Spirit -- Part 5
By James Thunder | March 12th 2025 11:45 AMAs observed at the beginning of this essay, the “after” picture vis-à-vis purgatory is that there are no more tears. Consider the soothing words of Eucharistic Prayer No. 3: “There [in Your kingdom] we hope to enjoy forever the fullness of Your glory, when You will wipe away every tear…
READ FULL BLOG POSTAnguish in Purgatory
Crying after death, and the balm given us by our love, the Holy Spirit -- Part 4
By James Thunder | March 11th 2025 11:06 AMLet us continue our query of what causes anguish for those in purgatory, starting with losses or lost opportunities and then the wounds inflicted by others. Henry David Thoreau wrote, “The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation. What is called resignation is confirmed desperation.”[1] In this…
READ FULL BLOG POST