The Narthex
Blessings, Grounded in Love
Truly pastoral counselling does not involve any development of doctrine
By James Hanink | December 21st 2023 12:31 PMThe Declaration Fiducia Supplicans, signed by Pope Francis, calls for our close attention. Its overarching context is the Church’s wealth of blessings, each a gift of God’s love, and their place in the economy of grace. The most frequent, and liturgically grounded, blessing comes at the conclusion of the Mass.…
READ FULL BLOG POSTUninformed Voters
Let’s encourage all the voters who aren’t informed and engaged to not vote
By James Hanink | December 13th 2023 3:31 PMIt’s a recognized conundrum in what’s called “social decision theory”: believe it or not, in a series of straight up or down votes (as with referenda), the majority can be in the minority in a majority of cases. Check out Anscombe’s Paradox. Here’s another conundrum. In a state-wide or national…
READ FULL BLOG POSTA Crack in the Wall
Philosophy is about much more than critical thinking and landing a job
By James Hanink | November 29th 2023 2:52 PMThe L.A. Times, a newspaper that I love to lambaste, seems to have a crack in its “wokeness wall.” A fresh editorial headline announces that “Students lose when colleges trade humanities for STEM” (Nov. 26). But wait! Science, tech, engineering, and math programs (STEM) now rule the academic roost. Is…
READ FULL BLOG POSTBefore Weeping, a Pause and a Prayer
Peace in the Middle East will be the work of justice
By James Hanink | November 14th 2023 2:44 PMEven in her nineties Rena Poulos, Inglewood’s restauranteur of renown, would ask paper-reading patrons, “Any good news yet?” These days would she even bother to ask? For my part, as a mid-septuagenarian, I’m attuned to the folly of youth. My own daughter hasn’t registered to vote, even though she could…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Determinist's Dilemmas
Absent free will, one is not free even to evaluate an argument
By James Hanink | October 27th 2023 8:10 PMNeurobiologist Robert Sapolsky recently captured a headline in the Los Angeles Times. “Humans lack free will, says Stanford scientist” (10-22-2023, B1). The subtitle drives home the point: “Decades of study lead to claim that virtually all behavior is beyond our conscious control.” So contends Sapolsky, the winner of a MacArthur…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPaying Attention
Simone Weil writes, ‘Attention, taken to its highest degree, is the same thing as prayer’
By James Hanink | October 18th 2023 8:02 PMImagine a protest in which activists chant, “What do we want? Free publicity! When do we want it? Now!” Easy enough, right? Isn’t it already the subtext of many demonstrations? Or imagine a political campaign soliciting money chiefly in order to solicit more money. Again, easy enough. Isn’t it the…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhat Mercy Is and Is Not
When we speak of mercy, we surely need to think of repentance
By James Hanink | October 5th 2023 11:53 AMSo often does Pope Francis speak of mercy that some wonder whether mercy has become an unconditional and universal absolution. It is not. Definitely not. Whatever his limits might be, Francis’s words about abortionists and arms merchants are anything but exculpatory. Indeed, St. John Paul II’s encyclical on mercy, Dives…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMacro-Matters & Wonder
Our faith leads us to embrace the universe and hold sacred the person
By James Hanink | September 20th 2023 11:28 AM“Philosophy begins in wonder.” So says Aristotle in his Metaphysics. Reflecting on this text, St. Thomas teaches that a goal of metaphysics is to establish the truth about the first and universal causes of things. If we achieve this goal, he writes, “there should be no wonder because the causes…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Measure of Conscience
On our sorry attempts at self-deception, both personal and societal
By James Hanink | September 6th 2023 11:49 AMClassical literature, unlike today’s invasive shlock, offers us a legacy of rich moral reflections. Two related instances come to mind. Both make insightful judgments about our sorry attempts at self-deception, both personal and societal. In his haunting novella The Death of Ivan Ilych (1886), Leo Tolstoy points out how often…
READ FULL BLOG POSTHumane Politics
We cannot realize our personal goods apart from the common good
By James Hanink | August 23rd 2023 11:55 AMThere’s no vacation -- etymologically, “empty time” -- in politics. Nor even “holidays,” though our holidays are far removed from true holydays. So, yes, I’m on the campaign trail again. Dianne Feinstein, California’s very senior senator, has reached the tender age of 90 and won’t be running again. Why not,…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWork, Good Work, and Counterfeits
Sometimes what gets called 'work' does not promote human flourishing
By James Hanink | August 9th 2023 11:32 AMCalifornia is a mixed bag, and here’s an example of just how mixed. We have a new Employee Ownership office, a government hub to help companies explore worker-owned models. The American Solidarity Party would applaud this effort. Indeed, its new party platform says: “We support regulatory and tax support to…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPluriform Blasphemy
Blasphemy in heart and in deed
By James Hanink | July 26th 2023 11:31 AMWe’re used to “in your face” demonstrations, and so are Swedes. But now Sweden is dealing with something more, the public burning of the Quran. Iran’s Ayatollah Ali Khamenei is furious: “The insult to the Holy Quran in Sweden is a bitter, conspiratorial, dangerous event. It is the opinion of…
READ FULL BLOG POSTConfusion or Obfuscation?
The Church cannot bless two people specifically in relation to a disordered coupling
By James Hanink | July 11th 2023 3:49 PMEndless print and online controversy can be a bit much. News from inside the Vatican, for example, can yield TMI—too much information. Beware the perils of second-hand theological controversy. Still, there are times when one might offer a comment or three. Consider some recent remarks of the Argentine theologian and…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPascal's Advice
The strongest reasons for God’s existence are acts of loving kindness
By James Hanink | June 28th 2023 2:47 PMRecently Pope Francis issued an Apostolic Letter on the French thinker Blaise Pascal (1623–1662). It comes on the Fourth Centenary of his birth. Francis chose a haunting title: On the Sublimity and Misery of Man (Sublimitas et Miseria Hominis). Most of Francis’s discussion centers on Pascal’s Pensées. Don’t expect to…
READ FULL BLOG POSTHumility in Pride Month
Yes, we counter falsehoods with truth, and we should do so with humility
By James Hanink | June 7th 2023 11:24 AMThere are decent politicians, and one whom I admire just won a nomination which he merited. In accepting it, he said “I am humbled by this honor.” He wasn’t virtue signaling, so I don’t suspect him of “false humility.” Still, we’d be gobsmacked were he to say that he was…
READ FULL BLOG POST