We have a little quiz for you. We want you to determine whether the following quote is pro-Bush, anti-Bush, neutral, or ambiguous. Here it is: The events of 9/11/2001 and the U.S. wars on Afghanistan and Iraq tempt Americans to retreat into isolationism . The continuing war on terrorism and the rebuilding of Afghanistan and Iraq, as well as the role the United States is playing, calls for Americans to reengage the world. Its time to stop circling the wagons and think of how all citizens of this world can work together better (ellipsis in original).
O.K., whats you decision? Pro-Bush, anti-Bush, neutral, or ambiguous?
Heres how we parse the quote: The events of 9/11/2001 and the U.S. wars on Afghanistan and Iraq [possibly anti-Bush; had it said in, it would clearly be neutral] tempt Americans to retreat into isolationism [pro-Bush; the isolationists didnt want the U.S. to go to war in Afghanistan and especially Iraq, and those who are calling for U.S. troops to leave Afghanistan and Iraq are isolationists] . The continuing war on terrorism and the rebuilding of Afghanistan and Iraq, as well as the role the United States is playing [pro-Bush; implies that we are successfully rebuilding those two countries and that we should continue with our rebuilding efforts], calls for Americans to reengage the world [ambiguous; we are engaging the world, so what it would mean to reengage the world is unclear, unless its an oblique call to involve the U.N. and much of Europe in the rebuilding efforts]. Its time to stop circling the wagons [pro-Bush; lets not be tempted to draw inward, bug out of Afghanistan and Iraq, and forget the world, though if it means were dissing the U.N. and much of Europe it could be anti-Bush] and think of how all citizens of this world can work together better [ambiguous mush].
All in all, our conclusion is this: The statement is fundamentally ambiguous, a muddled attempt to please all sides and offend no one.
But thats not how Deal Hudson read it (Crisis editorial, Feb. 2004). Hudson says it is an outburst of America-bashing and a blatantly ideological screed against President Bushs foreign policy.
You have two options:
- Online subscription: Subscribe now to New Oxford Review for access to all web content at newoxfordreview.org AND the monthly print edition for as low as $38 per year.
- Single article purchase: Purchase this article for $1.95, for viewing and printing for 48 hours.
If you're already a subscriber log-in here.